In Reply to: Copyright infringement is copyright infringement posted by J on March 22, 2007 at 13:42:08:
I appreciate your post, J, as I always do, and there is much truth in it. But all this extra-fine semantic parsing simply gives cover to thieves and those who sympathize with them.A friend of my wife's, a PHD no less, knew I was a writer and asked me what word processor I preferred. After I told her she asked me if she could copy my copy of the program. I asked her if she would similarly walk into CompUSA, stuff the program into her pants, and walk out without paying.
Like so many, she thought that was different!
I wonder what she teaches her kids.
I stipulate: the record companies and the RIAA are evil, rapacious, and stupid. (So was the company whose software I recommended.) And I stipulate that technically what is happening is copyright infringement under the law.
Well, the truth is, the law has no bearing on my argument.
Whenever this comes up I cannot believe I'm having the conversation. Crikey, this is third-grade catechism stuff. One is either willing to steal--and here you can name any extenuating circumstances you like--or not.
Sorry; you can't polish this turd, my friend.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- A distinction without a difference. - markrohr 14:24:27 03/22/07 (11)
- Lefsetz: "Piracy didn’t kill the major label business model, choice did." - J 18:26:14 03/22/07 (1)
- Perhaps you missed it. - markrohr 05:36:39 03/23/07 (0)
- The headline on this one... - J 18:07:05 03/22/07 (0)
- University of Nebraska takes Wisconsin's lead one step further - J 18:02:49 03/22/07 (0)
- "Whenever this comes up I cannot believe I'm having the conversation" - J 17:53:01 03/22/07 (0)
- I give cover to no thief - J 14:55:03 03/22/07 (5)
- Your Predicament..... - Todd Krieger 04:48:21 03/23/07 (4)
- To whom are you referring, Todd? nt - markrohr 05:22:54 03/23/07 (3)
- Re: To whom are you referring, Todd? nt - Todd Krieger 10:08:45 03/23/07 (2)
- Re: To whom are you referring, Todd? nt - markrohr 10:22:00 03/23/07 (1)
- Re: To whom are you referring, Todd? nt - Todd Krieger 11:31:53 03/23/07 (0)