Prokofiev's 2nd what? Symphony, Quartet or PC? Sorry but the rhythmic imagination, notice I didn't say

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - An Event: New Complete Bartok SQ's with the Heath Quartet, but Do They Beat the Early Juilliards? Will Anybody? - jdaniel@jps.net 09:16:15 06/08/17 (37)

Might have to tie me to a chair.... - Ivan303 07:44:24 06/09/17 (32)

Stand your ground, Ivan! The Bartok Quartets are wildly overrated IMHO! - Chris from Lafayette 09:52:21 06/09/17 (30)

OK, I am SERIOUSLY Shocked! You're both Fired. nt - oldmkvi 14:23:57 06/09/17 (0)

Silly. Bartok didn't write any overrated music. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 11:22:25 06/09/17 (28)

And furthermore. . . - Chris from Lafayette 11:35:34 06/09/17 (2)

You need a bigger bong. nt - Rick W 16:59:40 06/09/17 (1)

That MUST be what I'm missing! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 21:30:53 06/09/17 (0)

Sure he did - the String Quartets! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 11:30:54 06/09/17 (24)

RE: Sure he did - the String Quartets! [nt] ;-) - banpuku 15:00:47 06/09/17 (19)

Chris just isn't ready for Bartok. Remember: Solti didn't attempt to record Shostakovich until the end of his - jdaniel@jps.net 18:42:36 06/09/17 (18)

Not so - I like a lot of Bartok - Chris from Lafayette 21:01:44 06/09/17 (17)

Prokofiev's 2nd what? Symphony, Quartet or PC? Sorry but the rhythmic imagination, notice I didn't say - jdaniel@jps.net 21:30:53 06/09/17 (16)

The flash drive has arrived! - Won't be able to listen until Monday - Chris from Lafayette 21:43:09 06/09/17 (15)

Good! Was worried. Take your time. Just some promises before posting about it: - jdaniel@jps.net 07:58:07 06/10/17 (6)

I just checked the contents of the USB thumb drive - Chris from Lafayette 00:20:02 06/12/17 (4)

Comments are welcome! Of course, it's a given that they're not 5-channel. : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 08:05:06 06/12/17 (3)

OK - here goes - Chris from Lafayette 20:06:31 06/13/17 (2)

RE: OK - here goes - banpuku 08:55:43 06/14/17 (0)

Awesome, glad you enjoyed, the .49 cents was worth it. : ) - jdaniel@jps.net 20:44:51 06/13/17 (0)

Jeez - I've got to plow through that other stuff too??? - Chris from Lafayette 09:48:28 06/10/17 (0)

RE: The flash drive has arrived! - Won't be able to listen until Monday - banpuku 05:00:16 06/10/17 (7)

Hmm. . . I guess I've grown tired of all these composers who were always "breaking barriers" - Chris from Lafayette 09:46:31 06/10/17 (5)

Breaking Barriers - banpuku 10:36:10 06/10/17 (2)

That's very interesting - and who am I to say you're wrong? - Chris from Lafayette 20:57:11 06/10/17 (0)

RE: Breaking Barriers - pbarach 13:04:55 06/10/17 (0)

You just haven't heard them persuasively performed. : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 10:03:03 06/10/17 (1)

Not persuasive for me anyway - although I have heard a fair number of performances [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 21:00:34 06/10/17 (0)

Thank you, could not have said it better, though I hate to look at Prokofiev and Bartok as competing. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 07:59:19 06/10/17 (0)

I don't find any markings in the scores that instruct the players to "overrate" any passage whatsoever. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 11:59:34 06/09/17 (3)

Not the players - it's the academicians, critics and other hangers-on [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 13:48:48 06/09/17 (2)

i know. But none that is Bartok's fault. I just glad he wrote something that still excites me. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 14:28:00 06/09/17 (1)

I'm very happy for you! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 21:02:42 06/09/17 (0)

The 5th is probably easiest. Great "night music" movt and lots of toe-tapping dance rhythms. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 08:13:19 06/09/17 (0)

And I still like the Vegh performances very much - John N 07:04:30 06/09/17 (0)

RE: An Event: New Complete Bartok SQ's with the Heath Quartet, but Do They Beat the Early Juilliards? Will Anybody? - pbarach 15:02:38 06/08/17 (0)

Will Anybody? ...Tatrai, Hungarian - andy evans 13:56:22 06/08/17 (1)

I know those well from handsome lp sets, but still prefer J's. Cellist Hungarian iirc - jdaniel@jps.net 16:28:27 06/08/17 (0)

Follow Ups

Prokofiev's 2nd what? Symphony, Quartet or PC? Sorry but the rhythmic imagination, notice I didn't say - jdaniel@jps.net 21:30:53 06/09/17 (16)

The flash drive has arrived! - Won't be able to listen until Monday - Chris from Lafayette 21:43:09 06/09/17 (15)

Good! Was worried. Take your time. Just some promises before posting about it: - jdaniel@jps.net 07:58:07 06/10/17 (6)

I just checked the contents of the USB thumb drive - Chris from Lafayette 00:20:02 06/12/17 (4)

Comments are welcome! Of course, it's a given that they're not 5-channel. : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 08:05:06 06/12/17 (3)

OK - here goes - Chris from Lafayette 20:06:31 06/13/17 (2)

RE: OK - here goes - banpuku 08:55:43 06/14/17 (0)

Awesome, glad you enjoyed, the .49 cents was worth it. : ) - jdaniel@jps.net 20:44:51 06/13/17 (0)

Jeez - I've got to plow through that other stuff too??? - Chris from Lafayette 09:48:28 06/10/17 (0)

RE: The flash drive has arrived! - Won't be able to listen until Monday - banpuku 05:00:16 06/10/17 (7)

Hmm. . . I guess I've grown tired of all these composers who were always "breaking barriers" - Chris from Lafayette 09:46:31 06/10/17 (5)

Breaking Barriers - banpuku 10:36:10 06/10/17 (2)

That's very interesting - and who am I to say you're wrong? - Chris from Lafayette 20:57:11 06/10/17 (0)

RE: Breaking Barriers - pbarach 13:04:55 06/10/17 (0)

You just haven't heard them persuasively performed. : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 10:03:03 06/10/17 (1)

Not persuasive for me anyway - although I have heard a fair number of performances [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 21:00:34 06/10/17 (0)

Thank you, could not have said it better, though I hate to look at Prokofiev and Bartok as competing. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 07:59:19 06/10/17 (0)

Post a Message!