In Reply to: More. . . posted by Chris from Lafayette on April 7, 2015 at 10:54:24:
I've never understood how some people (and this is not directed at you, Andy, Scott or anyone else in this thread) endlessly argue that private enterprises should be free to do as they choose -- until a private enterprise does something they disagree with.This is not censorship, at least not in the American constitutional "freedom of speech" sense. The Toronto Symphony is a private enterprise and presumably can book or not book anyone they please (though Canadian law is not my area of expertise, I think it's similar in this area) just as Sony Pictures can choose not to release a satire about Kim Jong-Un or theaters can choose not to screen it. This kind of legal "private censorship" is routine and doesn't get much press except in extreme or excessively obvious cases.
People who don't like it should keep that in mind when considering the issue of government funding of the arts.
Edits: 04/07/15
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- On the other hand, - rbolaw 12:25:52 04/07/15 (26)
- Some good points from another Toronto newspaper - Chris from Lafayette 16:06:03 04/09/15 (4)
- One aspect of the current TSO thing I haven't seen mentioned is ticket sales. - Rick W 11:39:27 04/10/15 (2)
- RE: One aspect of the current TSO thing I haven't seen mentioned is ticket sales. - Analog Scott 15:25:45 04/10/15 (1)
- LOL :-) I would never have known about her tweets either if I hadn't seen the posts here. nt - Rick W 15:53:04 04/10/15 (0)
- The key statement in that article: - rbolaw 17:30:21 04/09/15 (0)
- RE: On the other hand, - Analog Scott 18:37:57 04/07/15 (9)
- RE: On the other hand, - David Smith 20:13:36 04/07/15 (8)
- RE: On the other hand, - Analog Scott 22:10:46 04/07/15 (7)
- RE: On the other hand, - Mali 08:32:50 04/09/15 (0)
- Its a tricky issue. - Rick W 10:03:06 04/08/15 (2)
- RE: Its a tricky issue. - Analog Scott 16:31:48 04/08/15 (0)
- RE: Its a tricky issue. - rbolaw 16:00:12 04/08/15 (0)
- RE: On the other hand, - rbolaw 06:26:17 04/08/15 (2)
- RE: On the other hand, - Analog Scott 08:14:59 04/08/15 (1)
- No argument from me there - rbolaw 10:56:11 04/08/15 (0)
- But then there's this from the CBC - Chris from Lafayette 17:20:32 04/07/15 (7)
- That's faulty analysis. - rbolaw 18:07:19 04/07/15 (6)
- But the Toronto Symphony is at least partially funded by the government, isn't it? - Chris from Lafayette 18:33:50 04/07/15 (5)
- Not enough, I guess - rbolaw 19:11:50 04/07/15 (4)
- "a decision like this can backfire" - Chris from Lafayette 19:30:04 04/07/15 (3)
- That's nothing new - rbolaw 05:56:12 04/08/15 (0)
- RE: Krystian Zimerman - Ivan303 20:24:55 04/07/15 (1)
- RE: Krystian Zimerman - Analog Scott 22:14:13 04/07/15 (0)
- Nicely said NT - lancelot 15:26:10 04/07/15 (0)
- I agree. - Rick W 15:16:40 04/07/15 (1)
- All very true - and good points from you both - Chris from Lafayette 15:41:21 04/07/15 (0)