In Reply to: Which Sherwood S-5000? posted by dee eye why on July 26, 2014 at 14:02:40:
OK, time for me to chime in. Yes, Mikey has rebuilt a ton of S5000 amps, and I have done I think 4 of them. I have done a few of the S8000 receivers and one or two others with the 7868 output tubes. All have their sonic virtues. I have done probably well over 300 rebuilds of various amps in the past few years so I have heard quite a variety of tube gear and have some basis for comparison :). We all have our tastes. There are a number of pieces with great reputations that I have heard that I thought were vastly over rated and quite frankly, built like crap. The Sherwoods were built to a much higher standard than most of the others. I prefer the little 7189/EL84 version for that little bit of sweetness. However, the 7868/7591 version is a very good amp and I totally agree that it will depend on what speakers you are using, what room, and your musical taste. They are both great amps. Mikey and I are buddies, we are not in an competition, our recipes for rebuilding them are pretty much the same. If you get one I would be happy to help you sort it out, and so would Mikey (I think), but I cannot speak for him and how long his queue is. Mine tends to run under 30 days most of the time.
I also agree with Eli D. in that these are great amps, they are one of the best little integrated amps I have ever heard, but they are not quite in the same league as my Citation I/II combo, especially on phono. That said, they are more than good enough for most folks and cost considerably less than separates. They will give you 75+% of the performance of a killer pair of separates and cost much less and take up far less space. If you can live with 13-15 watts/ch or 30 or so that you get out of the 7868/7591 version then you will be very happy. If you really push the 7189 version you can get a bit more than 15 watts/ch. Depends on how hard you want to run the output tubes. If you need more power then you are looking at separates. Let's put it this way. If I had to set up a great system on a budget I would probably start with the S5000 at the core. If cost were not an issue then I would start with a Citation II......
cheers,
don
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - dls123 07:13:08 07/29/14 (8)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - Michael Samra 11:13:00 07/30/14 (2)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - The_Gief 13:50:58 07/30/14 (1)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - Michael Samra 20:59:44 07/30/14 (0)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - rockdoc 11:52:02 07/29/14 (2)
- There's a coupla Sherwood tuners not far from me ... - PeterI 20:11:11 07/29/14 (0)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - Eli Duttman 19:55:12 07/29/14 (0)
- Excellent post. Thanks for your input. nt. - dee eye why 09:38:17 07/29/14 (0)
- RE: Which Sherwood S-5000? - airtime 09:31:57 07/29/14 (0)