In Reply to: I think these are exactly what she says they are. posted by Dave Pogue on August 5, 2014 at 04:56:54:
I'd like to think you're right. But there are some issues. First, several of them are described as Emtec 468 mastering tape, even though Emtec didn't make tape back then (since Emtec didn't exist) AND the reels and boxes are a variety of styles and brands AND 468 tape (whether BASF, Agfa, or Emtec) didn't exist when Fritz Reiner conducted the CSO. Also, there are two tapes (Decca - Rite of Spring, and RCA - Also Sprach Zarathustra), both with Scotch/3M boxes and reels, which both have a nice flat pack but both have a discontinuity at about 1.5 inches from the hub. I find this odd - two tapes from different record companies, identical reels, and identical discontinuities. Further, the labelling sucks, which a top pro recording engineer wouldn't do.
All of these factors would indicate that these are not original safety masters.
So, as I said in my earlier post, it's likely that these are copies from "somewhere". To give Reel-Lady the benefit of the doubt, she may not know the history of these tapes. Still, it's her site claiming they're on Emtec 468.
:)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: I think these are exactly what she says they are. - Inmate51 08:41:21 08/05/14 (6)
- I've asked her. - Dave Pogue 10:39:28 08/05/14 (5)
- I see no reason why a safety master need be made at the same time as the original. - Awe-d-o-file 05:20:05 08/06/14 (3)
- RE: I see no reason why a safety master need be made at the same time as the original. - mcgjohn@yahoo.com 09:44:11 08/06/14 (2)
- RE: I see no reason why a safety master need be made at the same time as the original. - c1ferrari 18:36:56 08/06/14 (0)
- Here is reel-lady's response. - Dave Pogue 11:06:09 08/06/14 (0)
- RE: I've asked her. - ironbut 12:54:30 08/05/14 (0)