In Reply to: RE: Semantics... posted by Naz on October 18, 2014 at 23:19:18:
"Can we agree that as the value of R increases the circuit tends more towards a CF?"
No, I don't agree. You're off the point, though. We're discussing the Baby Ongaku circuit as-is. You know, it's ironic that you're the same person who chastised me for needlessly describing this in such detail when people here supposedly already understand it. Clearly, that statement wasn't meant to be autobiographical.
"I still prefer the sound with the OP taken from the bottom tube's plate."
Does it matter? The circuit under discussion is incorrectly designed and has been misapplied. That's what you and Paul are listening to, a dysfunctional circuit with values no competent designer would use. How it sounds is irrelevant. Perform a scientific test with a legitimate SRPP, or a properly constructed totem pole running at favorable operating points, and your statement would be of interest.
Edits: 10/19/14
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- The Bottom Line - Triode_Kingdom 08:58:40 10/19/14 (15)
- Now this is getting tiresome .. - Naz 15:29:04 10/19/14 (9)
- RE: Now this is getting tiresome .. - Paul Joppa 19:26:44 10/20/14 (8)
- RE: Now this is getting tiresome .. - Naz 19:55:47 10/20/14 (7)
- Larger Swing - Triode_Kingdom 08:04:45 10/21/14 (6)
- One last try at convincing you ... - Naz 06:13:54 10/23/14 (5)
- RE: One last try at convincing you ... - Triode_Kingdom 13:21:35 10/23/14 (4)
- RE: One last try at convincing you ... - Naz 14:47:52 10/23/14 (3)
- SPICE Results - Triode_Kingdom 19:47:41 10/23/14 (2)
- The ASC Files here for anyone to verify! - Naz 22:36:52 10/23/14 (1)
- RE: The ASC Files here for anyone to verify! - Triode_Kingdom 08:53:13 10/24/14 (0)
- How to Improve It - Triode_Kingdom 10:13:44 10/19/14 (4)
- OK, for the sake of furthering the discussion ... - Naz 17:39:38 10/19/14 (3)
- That's a different topic, so I'm out - Triode_Kingdom 20:04:58 10/19/14 (2)
- Not so fast ... - Naz 21:34:27 10/19/14 (1)
- Simulation - Triode_Kingdom 12:50:34 10/20/14 (0)