In Reply to: RE: Semantics... posted by Triode_Kingdom on October 18, 2014 at 17:07:04:
I don't see any circuits but if you substitute the top triode with a resistor the bottom tube obviously functions as a grounded cathode.
I will concede however that in order for the top tube to function as a CF the resistor value needs to increase significantly. Can we agree that as the value of R increases the circuit tends more towards a CF?
Ultimately, to make the circuit something I would use the R value would need to increase significantly requiring a circuit change such as swapping the R with an L or CCS or adding a cap. I like such variations of the circuit and use them a lot but never use the circuit under discussion exactly as it. Even so I still prefer the sound with the OP taken from the bottom tube's plate.
Back to the circuit with the current values, even swapping the top tube with an R will still sound different regardless of the technicalities IMO. To believe otherwise is to believe that there is no difference in the sound of components including tubes.
Naz
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Semantics... - Naz 23:19:18 10/18/14 (16)
- The Bottom Line - Triode_Kingdom 08:58:40 10/19/14 (15)
- Now this is getting tiresome .. - Naz 15:29:04 10/19/14 (9)
- RE: Now this is getting tiresome .. - Paul Joppa 19:26:44 10/20/14 (8)
- RE: Now this is getting tiresome .. - Naz 19:55:47 10/20/14 (7)
- Larger Swing - Triode_Kingdom 08:04:45 10/21/14 (6)
- One last try at convincing you ... - Naz 06:13:54 10/23/14 (5)
- RE: One last try at convincing you ... - Triode_Kingdom 13:21:35 10/23/14 (4)
- RE: One last try at convincing you ... - Naz 14:47:52 10/23/14 (3)
- SPICE Results - Triode_Kingdom 19:47:41 10/23/14 (2)
- The ASC Files here for anyone to verify! - Naz 22:36:52 10/23/14 (1)
- RE: The ASC Files here for anyone to verify! - Triode_Kingdom 08:53:13 10/24/14 (0)
- How to Improve It - Triode_Kingdom 10:13:44 10/19/14 (4)
- OK, for the sake of furthering the discussion ... - Naz 17:39:38 10/19/14 (3)
- That's a different topic, so I'm out - Triode_Kingdom 20:04:58 10/19/14 (2)
- Not so fast ... - Naz 21:34:27 10/19/14 (1)
- Simulation - Triode_Kingdom 12:50:34 10/20/14 (0)