In Reply to: Measurement and Perception and the Value of Each (Long Post) posted by jrlaudio on November 3, 2012 at 00:46:42:
The Venn diagram describes a set of possible sonic differences. A is the set of differences that can be discriminated by available measurements. B is the set of differences that can be discriminated by discerning listeners.
You are misusing logic when you conclude that the existence of differences that can be measured but not heard (the non-overlapping portion of the left hand circle) implies that all differences that can be heard can also be measured. B also includes the non-overlapping portion of the right hand circle.
Tony Lauck
"Diversity is the law of nature; no two entities in this universe are uniform." - P.R. Sarkar
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- You are logically challenged. - Tony Lauck 09:34:47 11/03/12 (54)
- RE: You forgot - BigguyinATL 19:21:16 02/16/13 (0)
- Please Tony.... - Goober58 08:44:19 11/06/12 (48)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Tony Lauck 09:06:34 11/06/12 (47)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Goober58 09:32:08 11/06/12 (46)
- Sorry to break in, but - geoffkait 11:08:54 11/06/12 (24)
- I think so but what's that got to do with this discussion? - Goober58 13:52:00 11/06/12 (23)
- It's got everything to do with it. - geoffkait 14:52:41 11/06/12 (22)
- That's not how I read it and you aren't making much of a case for you own claim... - Goober58 15:25:19 11/06/12 (21)
- RE: "PERIOD!" - More like SEMICOLON - geoffkait 18:35:16 11/06/12 (20)
- I believed I heard a difference when I used my magic chip - Goober58 21:33:21 11/06/12 (19)
- RE: "Unfortunately the disks I selected as being improved were not the ones processed." - geoffkait 00:47:06 11/07/12 (18)
- Oh? - Goober58 10:37:20 11/07/12 (17)
- Hmmmm - geoffkait 11:10:14 11/07/12 (16)
- Yep - Goober58 11:51:26 11/07/12 (15)
- Outlier - geoffkait 12:47:56 11/07/12 (14)
- RE: Outlier - Goober58 14:28:15 11/07/12 (13)
- RE: Outlier - geoffkait 15:53:21 11/07/12 (12)
- RE: Outlier - Goober58 17:00:07 11/07/12 (11)
- RE: "...in each set of three" - geoffkait 05:55:24 11/08/12 (10)
- RE: "...in each set of three" - Goober58 06:42:12 11/08/12 (9)
- RE: 9 different CDs - geoffkait 08:05:44 11/08/12 (8)
- That didn't matter to me - Goober58 09:57:02 11/08/12 (5)
- Good enough won't cut it. - Tony Lauck 11:30:04 11/08/12 (1)
- Sorry Tony but good enough does cut it - Goober58 13:17:23 11/08/12 (0)
- These things happen (for a reason) - geoffkait 10:16:16 11/08/12 (2)
- RE: These things happen (for a reason) - Goober58 13:05:51 11/08/12 (1)
- RE: These things happen (for a reason) - geoffkait 16:26:41 11/08/12 (0)
- Loving thoughts - Tony Lauck 09:04:26 11/08/12 (1)
- RE: Loving thoughts - geoffkait 09:33:46 11/08/12 (0)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Tony Lauck 09:41:34 11/06/12 (20)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Goober58 15:59:52 11/06/12 (19)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Tony Lauck 16:44:15 11/06/12 (18)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Goober58 10:50:38 11/07/12 (17)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Tony Lauck 11:07:24 11/07/12 (16)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Goober58 12:10:24 11/07/12 (15)
- Yet... - E-Stat 14:32:27 11/07/12 (13)
- RE: Yet... - Goober58 06:51:49 11/08/12 (10)
- RE: Yet... - E-Stat 07:02:48 11/08/12 (9)
- RE: Yet... - Goober58 10:08:50 11/08/12 (8)
- RE: Yet... - E-Stat 10:21:38 11/08/12 (7)
- How should I know? - Goober58 15:07:42 11/08/12 (6)
- RE: How should I know? - E-Stat 15:38:09 11/08/12 (5)
- RE: How should I know? - Goober58 16:00:41 11/08/12 (4)
- RE: How should I know? - E-Stat 16:18:16 11/08/12 (3)
- RE: How should I know? - Goober58 17:03:59 11/08/12 (2)
- RE: How should I know? - E-Stat 17:15:48 11/08/12 (1)
- What a tired strawman - Goober58 18:13:18 11/08/12 (0)
- But... - kerr 17:31:19 11/07/12 (1)
- Some - E-Stat 06:57:03 11/09/12 (0)
- RE: Please Tony.... - Tony Lauck 12:17:44 11/07/12 (0)
- RE: You are logically challenged. - jrlaudio 10:06:01 11/03/12 (3)
- You are philosophically challenged as well - Tony Lauck 10:26:31 11/03/12 (2)
- RE: You are philosophically challenged as well - jrlaudio 11:28:20 11/03/12 (1)
- RE: You are philosophically challenged as well - Tony Lauck 12:02:06 11/03/12 (0)