Propeller Head Plaza

Go to the back of the class!

72.75.15.32

This Post Has Been Edited by the Author

In Reply to: RE: I'm afraid you'll have to judge my knowledge of the laws of sound propagation from the content of my post posted by andy19191 on September 16, 2007 at 10:20:00

You fail to grasp the original point of my mentioning the article -- that supposed scientific experts in the field jumped to the same conclusion you and numerous others have: the concept of the "rocks in jar" sounds too ridiculous to investigate further, thus should be pronounced "rubbish." Ditto for the readers of that austere publication. Arrogance and ingorance, plain and simple.
As for your argument, it continues to be a Appeal to Authority, a rather weak one at that. Can I suggest you get a hold of the Skeptics Handbook? You will be better prepared and have higher entertainment value when trolling these waters.
~ Cheerio

Edits: 09/16/07

Follow Ups: