24.70.95.205
In Reply to: RE: PC Audio - how to get close to vinyl sound posted by DBB on March 10, 2008 at 12:25:59
"So does rolling off the highs with a digital equalizer.(I can hear the boos, but try it.)"
Very interesting. What Frequency? Slope? Filter Q?
We *all* have a filter in the D/A conversion stage anyways! Filters for DA circuits have always been a source of much argument; which sound better, which are theoretically better, which fall down in practice...
Let's say if someone was listening to a vocalist, or choir or spoken word and preferred a filter at 18K on the material. Would he/she be crazy THEN?
Is *all* of the 'sizzle and sparkle' on percussion and chimes the same sizzle and sparkle that puts edge on vocals, the flute and certain string instruments?
Since we're using a filter anyways, I think your idea is not so crazy. In fact, with some REALLY top notch high end high buck DACs, the user can *select* from different filter topologies! Now why would they do THAT? Also, some argue that upsampling has a single good reason for being done in that it jacks up the nyquist frequency and thus the frequency of the anti-aliasing filter that can be used. Some strongly believe that moving this filter further away from the audible bandwidth is a desireable effect.
Good post. Made me think a little bit...
CHeers,
Presto
Follow Ups: