In Reply to: RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM posted by Tony Lauck on July 11, 2014 at 07:11:38:
The SATA cable is involved only when the data is loaded into RAM.
On the face of it, that would seem almost self-evident but it's not, in my experience, the whole story.
My audio PC uses a good embedded mobo (Fit-PC2) with a John Swenson designed (i.e. good) C-L-C PSU and two TPR regulators, one at 12v for the CPU and another at 5v for the SSD. The Win_XP OS is "slimmed" to within a inch of its life - data are read off the SSD at boot time only. I use RBCD files exclusively without upsampling. There is no KVM - music and control data are passed via LAN. (Though the system hangs at the end of the current track, I have in the past switched off the SSD during play without ill-effect. That persuades me that the SSD is not accessed during play.)
The drive would normally be powered via the mobo's SATA socket but I provided a dedicated 5v line as much, to be honest, because it was cheap and easy to implement as the result of any systematic testing.
Not long ago, wanting to pinch the 5v regulator circuit to use elsewhere, I popped the SSD back into the Fit-PC2. There was an unexpected but dramatic drop in SQ. The SATA interface might well not be passing data but it was certainly doing something deleterious - the drive was back on its 5v reg PDQ. I cannot say how "busy" SSDs are when nominally idle but my guess is pretty busy.
Bits-is-bits wallahs can ignore the issue as they choose but I was certainly reminded of it on this occasion.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - Ryelands 07:54:18 07/11/14 (11)
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - Ugly 18:18:56 07/11/14 (10)
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - Ryelands 02:45:45 07/12/14 (9)
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - rick_m 09:37:12 07/12/14 (0)
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - Ugly 08:12:44 07/12/14 (6)
- an improperly applied shield - fmak 02:25:13 07/13/14 (4)
- RE: an improperly applied shield - Ugly 10:14:46 07/13/14 (3)
- RE: an improperly applied shield -sorry - fmak 23:25:05 07/13/14 (2)
- RE: an improperly applied shield -sorry - Ugly 23:57:21 07/13/14 (1)
- RE: an improperly applied shield -sorry - Tony Lauck 07:21:41 07/14/14 (0)
- To correct an error in my previous post. - Ugly 10:44:48 07/12/14 (0)
- RE: with the data going over the SATA cable to RAM - Tony Lauck 08:02:10 07/12/14 (0)