In Reply to: OK now I am totally confused... posted by Penguin on June 4, 2012 at 19:58:25:
First of all, neither Ralph (I am sure) nor I want to take the responsibility for what might happen as a consequence of any of these mods. So, neither he nor I want to be on record as advocating anything that goes against the advice given by Sound Lab (i.e., Dr. West) regarding the use of their speakers. I can only tell you what I have done, at my own risk, to my speakers, and what the results were. Dr. West is on record as stating that it is not "safe" to remove the parallel resistor that comprises part of the hi-pass filter in front of the SL toroidal treble transformer. Dr. West stated that in part that resistor is in place to protect the toroid against musical transients that might damage it. In practice, I can tell you that I and a few others did remove that resistor; in my case I also changed the value of the capacitor from 36uF (factory) to 22uF. (I did this while I was waiting for the Australian transformers that now completely replace the toroid to arrive at my home.) The reason I reduced capacitance from 36 to 22uF is to preserve the crossover point or the "knee" of the hi-pass filter at about 550Hz. That is the factory-implemented crossover point when the resistor is in place. I calculated the value of 22uF based on measurements made with my own relatively new 845PXs. (Ergo, I cannot guarantee that this is the best value for anyone else's speakers.) I can tell you also that there was a big improvement in sound with the resistor gone and the capacitance at 22uF, and there were no ill effects on the toroid. If you were to remove the parallel resistor and NOT alter the capacitance, then the crossover point would be at a lower frequency (~350Hz). This, IMO, increases the risk that the toroid could be damaged; it was not designed to handle extreme low frequencies. Proceed at your own risk.
One mod I can recommend unconditionally is the removal of the "Brilliance Control", which is anything but. If you have not done that, try it.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: OK now I am totally confused... - Lew 07:01:19 06/05/12 (29)
- RE: OK now I am totally confused... - tyu 09:37:42 06/05/12 (0)
- RE: OK now I am totally confused... - Ralph 08:56:55 06/05/12 (27)
- I tried it with a 24uF cap and sounded horrible - Penguin 18:12:52 06/06/12 (15)
- RE: I tried it with a 24uF cap and sounded horrible - Lew 15:01:14 06/07/12 (2)
- I did not try it with the MA1 - Penguin 20:01:49 06/07/12 (1)
- taking just the resistor did not work - Penguin 21:24:44 06/07/12 (0)
- RE: I tried it with a 24uF cap and sounded horrible - Ralph 07:46:55 06/07/12 (11)
- Very distorted on bass and transients like an amp clipping - Penguin 08:44:19 06/07/12 (10)
- RE: Very distorted on bass and transients like an amp clipping - Ralph 10:16:31 06/07/12 (9)
- Not the removal of cap:) - Penguin 12:42:00 06/07/12 (8)
- RE: Not the removal of cap:) - Ralph 14:41:52 06/07/12 (7)
- exactly.... - Penguin 20:12:26 06/07/12 (6)
- RE: exactly.... - Ralph 08:48:45 06/08/12 (5)
- hmmm - Penguin 10:32:03 06/08/12 (4)
- Another way to think of it - Lew 22:54:30 06/08/12 (2)
- or just simply - Penguin 08:19:51 06/09/12 (1)
- RE: or just simply - tyu 08:53:15 06/09/12 (0)
- RE: hmmm - Ralph 11:45:56 06/08/12 (0)
- RE: OK now I am totally confused... - Lew 12:35:34 06/05/12 (10)
- I was using a different chart - Ralph 13:49:13 06/05/12 (9)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Lew 19:18:09 06/05/12 (8)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Ralph 09:07:15 06/06/12 (7)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Lew 06:56:24 06/07/12 (6)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Ralph 07:51:46 06/07/12 (2)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Lew 14:55:45 06/07/12 (1)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Ralph 08:41:04 06/08/12 (0)
- RE: I was using a different chart - KIS 07:31:47 06/07/12 (2)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Lew 14:51:35 06/07/12 (1)
- RE: I was using a different chart - Ralph 09:22:17 06/08/12 (0)