In Reply to: RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads posted by cookiemarenco on May 11, 2015 at 10:14:51:
Thanks for the explanation re: HD Tracks.
I was an early adopter of SACD and to a lesser extent DVD-A. I was also an early consumer of hi-res downloads and so far I've spent a couple grand on downloads. Like I said, I am happy to pay more for a better product. A lot of that money has gone to HD Tracks. I'll admit that my waning support is mostly due to the experiences I've had with them.
Aside from the sales tactics, my biggest gripe is wildly varying quality. There have been upsampled 44.1k recordings, hi-res remasters of classic recordings which have been compressed like modern pop recordings, and other related ills. I started to feel like I was playing the lottery, hoping for that elusive gem. I've had more success finding quality by seeking out old (non-remastered) CD pressings and certain imports than hi-res downloads.
I won't buy anything from HD Tracks anymore unless someone else has already dissected the release and I can find an FFT and DR stats and some listening comparisons to other releases. No more of this buyer beware we just post whatever the label gives us and don't forget your 20% discount pass is going to expire if you don't buy today. And I just don't have the time & patience to do that research except for titles that are practically a must-buy for me.
One thing that would help sell me on the product is providing the provenance of the release. This is where you have an advantage. I have a few of your CDs (but no downloads) and I know a bit about how you produce music, so I have more confidence. With HD Tracks, they get their content from the labels and don't seem to ask any questions; it's quantity over quality.
I realize that people like you and Jared are trying to maintain high standards in an industry where it seems like production quality has been on an extended downturn and consumers don't want to pay for music anymore. It can't be easy. But $40-50 is a lot to ask, and I will only pay that much if it's great music and demo quality sound.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - Dave_K 18:58:03 05/11/15 (13)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - Sordidman 10:48:08 05/12/15 (12)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - jamestavegia@gmail.com 03:42:48 05/13/15 (11)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - Dave_K 04:32:16 05/14/15 (10)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - jamestavegia@gmail.com 05:57:44 05/14/15 (9)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - Sordidman 09:44:17 05/14/15 (8)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - jamestavegia@gmail.com 15:53:32 05/14/15 (7)
- How can less than 10,000 SA-CDs & files be representative - Sordidman 09:46:18 05/19/15 (5)
- RE: How can less than 10,000 SA-CDs & files be representative - jamestavegia@gmail.com 13:44:34 05/19/15 (4)
- There is no demand for hi-rez - Sordidman 14:21:45 05/19/15 (3)
- RE: There is no demand for hi-rez // Not yet - Mr_Steady 19:35:09 05/19/15 (2)
- From my experience, I can't argue with anything you said - Sordidman 10:21:24 05/20/15 (1)
- RE: From my experience, I can't argue with anything you said - Mr_Steady 16:40:13 05/21/15 (0)
- RE: Pricing and Costs of SACD and DSD / High Res downloads - Dave_K 11:30:23 05/15/15 (0)