In Reply to: Since it's my practice... posted by Jim Treanor on December 21, 2004 at 09:24:39:
"to neither praise nor damn something I haven't heard"I think that we all would do better to keep that thought in mind more often...
The debate: (what does it take for SOTA redbook to equal SACD performance and at what level is SACD playback surpassed, - if at all by SOTA redbook), - is very interesting to me.
Necessarily, - there's going to be a big subjective, "as I hear it" qualification.
I really, really, like and have heard the Audio Aero Capitole II, with tweaks, at length, - and have "felt" that that system would better at least some SACD players. I get the feeling that no $1K or $2-$3K Universal player is going to play any format as good as the AA's redbook. But I haven't performed a shoot out either. (I also have heard DRAMATIC differences between certain player's SACD and redbook sections, - in which I sometimes suspect that the redbook section is purposely under-engineered in order to make the SACD section sound better: but I'm willing to admit that that could be paranoia on my part). I also need to remember that the CD is recorded in SACD, and those are not all created equal.
Wouldn't it be fun to compare some SOTA redbook with a crop of $3K - $4K SACD players, a maybe a $10K SOTA SACD too?
is this the real me, or a mere facsimile?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Wow.... that was a really nice post........ - Sordidman 09:44:36 12/21/04 (11)
- Agreed - that was paranoia on your part - Metralla 15:39:20 12/21/04 (10)
- Fair enough........ - Sordidman 09:47:06 12/22/04 (6)
- i bought my xa777es purely on its strength as a cd player ... - Christine Tham 17:53:30 12/22/04 (5)
- You are one of a kind, Christine - jeromelang 21:35:29 12/22/04 (4)
- A recent anecdote ... - Christine Tham 22:38:10 12/22/04 (3)
- Not me......... I agree that SACD sounds "better" - Sordidman 09:06:32 12/23/04 (2)
- Re: Not me......... I agree that SACD sounds "better" - Christine Tham 12:10:30 12/23/04 (1)
- Thanks for the tip. I hadn't realized the distinction - Sordidman 12:24:03 12/23/04 (0)
- Never say Never, It was proven for DSOTM (nt) - vettracer 07:34:35 12/22/04 (2)
- OOPS! I guess I should actually read rather than scan (nt) - vettracer 11:51:15 12/22/04 (0)
- DSOTM is not an SACD player... - rebop 09:09:03 12/22/04 (0)