In Reply to: Liner Notes Aren't Reliable? posted by randyC on January 12, 2004 at 11:04:20:
The pcm source was recorded over to DSD and edited there for the SACD master.
Best Regards,Michael Bishop
Recording Engineer
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - Duilawyer 18:27:00 01/09/04 (119)
- I'm waiting for the apology/slaps his forehead post. - detayls 16:53:04 01/12/04 (0)
- So you found an SACD that's no better than the CD, what do you want? A cookie? - sxr71 00:40:43 01/12/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek = PCM source - Michael Bishop 08:26:57 01/11/04 (3)
- Liner Notes Aren't Reliable? - randyC 11:04:20 01/12/04 (1)
- not complete - Michael Bishop 18:12:11 01/12/04 (0)
- Nickel Creek Surround Mix - bmoura 19:49:59 01/11/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - oldmkvi 12:27:10 01/10/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - triple_A 11:52:38 01/10/04 (0)
- Multichannel = big difference - Bobby_N 10:29:24 01/10/04 (0)
- I am listening to Nickel Creek DSD layer right now... - panorama 07:47:15 01/10/04 (2)
- You get the "I don't get it" prize. Put on the redbook layer. - Duilawyer 08:58:46 01/10/04 (1)
- I did. You know what??? It sounds better on DSD....and guess what else? - panorama 09:03:37 01/10/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - Khorn 07:40:14 01/10/04 (4)
- Non-answer. "The difference is one you.. - Duilawyer 09:00:39 01/10/04 (3)
- Ok, You want to play stupid games: PROVE to us that.... - Khorn 10:28:55 01/10/04 (2)
- Hearing acuity? - Jack Seaton 21:10:31 01/10/04 (0)
- Re: Ok, You want to play stupid games: PROVE to us that.... - regmac 11:37:06 01/10/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - regmac 07:13:53 01/10/04 (17)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - Peter 11:52:10 01/10/04 (10)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - regmac 13:13:15 01/10/04 (9)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - Peter 03:28:41 01/11/04 (4)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - regmac 09:37:13 01/11/04 (3)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - Peter 00:33:49 01/12/04 (0)
- Tone it down a little or I'll start deleting posts which aren't in the spirit of the rules... - Ted Smith 13:26:19 01/11/04 (1)
- Re: Tone it down a little or I'll start deleting posts which aren't in the spirit of the rules... - Peter 03:21:24 01/12/04 (0)
- Have you compared the XB940 with and without? - Stephen 16:28:11 01/10/04 (1)
- Re: Have you compared the XB940 with and without? - Peter 03:32:07 01/11/04 (0)
- Boy, you woke up on DUI's side of the bed today! [nt] - Ted Smith 13:20:20 01/10/04 (1)
- Let's hope it was a different bed. nt - Methos 19:00:48 01/10/04 (0)
- Where does my 555 rate-affordable, or high end? - Duilawyer 09:09:06 01/10/04 (5)
- Re: Where does my 555 rate-affordable, or high end? - Peter 03:44:07 01/11/04 (0)
- Re: Where does my 555 rate-affordable, or high end? - regmac 11:28:35 01/10/04 (3)
- Re: Where does my 555 rate-affordable, or high end? - Khorn 06:43:16 01/11/04 (0)
- Re: Where does my 555 rate-affordable, or high end? - Ted Smith 11:48:01 01/10/04 (1)
- Ditto! - oldmkvi 12:30:06 01/10/04 (0)
- I believe it was Marie Antoinette who said, - sgb 06:54:11 01/10/04 (0)
- Here we go again..... - MT 06:41:17 01/10/04 (4)
- No, others always move it from music\hi rez, to personal attacks. - Duilawyer 09:06:17 01/10/04 (2)
- ...and there are a few who simply wonder why you're demanding to have subjective judgements objectified. - Methos 11:06:18 01/10/04 (1)
- Whichever Format Is Cheaper - Robertc88 09:17:53 01/11/04 (0)
- A Lawyer Perhaps But Cannot Get His Money Back! - Robertc88 07:54:47 01/10/04 (0)
- You know those prints that mimic the topography of the original paintings? - Penguin 06:38:45 01/10/04 (1)
- Excellent analogy. (nt) - Dalton 11:28:36 01/10/04 (0)
- Easy, DUI - Eric LeRouge 05:29:21 01/10/04 (15)
- Thanks. Can't $hoot for the Offrande. :-) nt - Duilawyer 09:29:08 01/10/04 (1)
- There's always the used market if that's what you want - Eric LeRouge 11:55:24 01/11/04 (0)
- Re: Easy, DUI - smargo 06:58:27 01/10/04 (1)
- I thought I was being practical - Eric LeRouge 07:01:51 01/10/04 (0)
- you french Eric? trying to work on my french... - NonA 06:02:20 01/10/04 (10)
- Très français, monsieur Anon.. - Eric LeRouge 07:00:13 01/10/04 (9)
- Merci bien pour ton offre mon chere EricL. - NonA 10:37:41 01/10/04 (3)
- intéressant... - Eric LeRouge 08:04:50 01/11/04 (0)
- Never mind, I found the CD (screw the SACD) - NonA 11:58:19 01/10/04 (1)
- Re: Never mind, I found the CD (screw the SACD) - Eric LeRouge 07:54:03 01/11/04 (0)
- Re: Très français, monsieur Anon.. - patrickU 09:08:45 01/10/04 (4)
- I agree, Patrick.. - Eric LeRouge 08:07:58 01/11/04 (3)
- Re: I agree, Patrick.. - patrickU 08:12:13 01/11/04 (2)
- Ballet? - Eric LeRouge 11:46:57 01/11/04 (1)
- Re: Ballet? - patrickU 12:26:02 01/11/04 (0)
- Here is what I hear - theob 04:51:58 01/10/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - cf@tiscali.se 03:54:44 01/10/04 (0)
- Have You Compared Any Of The MoFi Recordings? - Robertc88 03:50:23 01/10/04 (0)
- You have demonstarted time and again that you have tin ears, not golden ears. - oldmkvi 23:49:27 01/09/04 (0)
- Re: CD vs. SACD-Nickel Creek-no sonic difference. - smargo 23:10:36 01/09/04 (0)
- Final score: 12 posts, by 5 members-not one fact\example. - Duilawyer 22:43:54 01/09/04 (2)
- Here's one I gave you a long time ago... - rebop 08:58:18 01/10/04 (0)
- You've got us beat, I admit - Stephen 22:49:24 01/09/04 (0)
- Perhaps you should... - Jim Treanor 22:23:20 01/09/04 (6)
- Another non-answer. We'll call that, an "I don't know, but - Duilawyer 22:33:51 01/09/04 (5)
- Not an attempt to answer...simply an observation... - Jim Treanor 10:50:01 01/10/04 (4)
- Re: Not an attempt to answer...simply an observation... - regmac 11:41:29 01/11/04 (3)
- why bother? - tunenut 15:41:15 01/11/04 (2)
- Re: why bother? - regmac 18:29:26 01/11/04 (1)
- Re: why bother? - Ted Smith 19:59:40 01/11/04 (0)
- Viva la difference - John B 20:53:06 01/09/04 (0)
- I hear quite a difference continuously, sorry if you don't - Ted Smith 19:12:30 01/09/04 (7)
- Odd; I did a search under "Nickel" and there are no posts in your name. - Duilawyer 19:24:17 01/09/04 (5)
- I hear the same differences on each disk... - Ted Smith 21:48:58 01/09/04 (4)
- "the same differences on each disk" AGAIN: Which disc? Nickel Creek? - Duilawyer 22:32:45 01/09/04 (3)
- Re: "the same differences on each disk" AGAIN: Which disc? Nickel Creek? - Ted Smith 11:14:23 01/10/04 (2)
- Agreed..but.. - SoftwireEngineer 16:21:46 01/10/04 (1)
- Re: Agreed..but.. - Ted Smith 16:37:10 01/10/04 (0)
- "I'm not going to list the differences again "; Just one??!! - Duilawyer 19:16:35 01/09/04 (0)
- We got it already... - honshued 18:52:19 01/09/04 (31)
- The "but you buy them" has been answered here endlessly - Duilawyer 19:01:41 01/09/04 (30)
- Dui, I am a supporter of both formats and would like to say... - rick5 20:50:59 01/09/04 (8)
- Much Cheaper To Upgrade Hardware - Robertc88 06:15:48 01/10/04 (0)
- Great post, BTW. nt. - Duilawyer 21:38:06 01/09/04 (0)
- Good examples. Give me a time and track. Pick attack when? - Duilawyer 21:35:59 01/09/04 (5)
- nothing to do with sacd - hifitommy 22:22:50 01/09/04 (4)
- nice words, but no truth to it. - Duilawyer 22:39:34 01/09/04 (3)
- it sounds like - hifitommy 08:50:24 01/10/04 (0)
- Say What? - honshued 00:18:21 01/10/04 (0)
- Objection - Jazz Inmate 23:54:42 01/09/04 (0)
- I would say that whole albums sound different on SACD, not just isolated passages... - Methos 20:22:17 01/09/04 (9)
- LOL: That is the dumbest weasely dodge ever. - Duilawyer 20:28:19 01/09/04 (8)
- Bet you've got Gaucho. How about it, then? I'll list some differences, you tell me you can't hear them. :-) nt - Methos 21:15:35 01/09/04 (4)
- On this one, I can plainly hear a tram go past at 1:06 into track 7 (nt) - Stephen 21:24:30 01/09/04 (3)
- No sh*t? Once Dui verifies possession of this disc, I'll check on that. :-) nt - Methos 21:30:15 01/09/04 (2)
- I'll have to get a copy too! (nt) - Stephen 21:32:57 01/09/04 (1)
- ...so you can hear the tram...and Fagan's fart at :07 of track 2. nt - Methos 21:35:40 01/09/04 (1)
- Nothing weasely about admitting I don't have the album to compare, is there dui? - Methos 20:41:41 01/09/04 (2)
- How many replies have you posted? How many ANSWERS? 0. - Duilawyer 22:38:05 01/09/04 (1)
- It looks like you're the one who's dodging, dui...I offered to take you up on your challenge, you said nothing in reply. - Methos 23:42:23 01/09/04 (0)
- Would you be so kind as to answer it one more time? (nt) - honshued 19:23:14 01/09/04 (10)
- Re: Would you be so kind as to answer it one more time? (nt) - Duilawyer 19:44:13 01/09/04 (9)
- Re: Would you be so kind as to answer it one more time? (nt) - Stephen 20:22:34 01/09/04 (2)
- AGAIN, no track, no time. No specifics, just insults. - Duilawyer 20:33:14 01/09/04 (1)
- Don't tell anybody I told you this ... - Stephen 21:02:00 01/09/04 (0)
- Thanks, but on my system... - honshued 20:17:33 01/09/04 (5)
- Player Better For Redbook - Robertc88 06:28:36 01/10/04 (0)
- Uhm, possible explanation. I like it! Tracks and times? - Duilawyer 20:24:28 01/09/04 (3)
- What part of every track of every hybrid I own didn`t you quite understand? - honshued 20:51:39 01/09/04 (2)
- Still you have dodged? Which track, which instrument? - Duilawyer 22:46:01 01/09/04 (1)
- Track 1 The Who:Tommy (drums)..... - honshued 23:05:53 01/09/04 (0)
- You'd be a sucker to buy any more, right? (nt) - Stephen 18:30:00 01/09/04 (3)
- I hope he agrees with you. Silence would be golden. nt - Biencfg 19:28:19 01/09/04 (1)
- Put up or shut up. Tracks? Times? Sonic difference? - Duilawyer 20:35:00 01/09/04 (0)
- See my post, above. nt - Duilawyer 19:03:15 01/09/04 (0)
Follow Ups
- not complete - Michael Bishop 18:12:11 01/12/04 (0)