In Reply to: Re: Curious why you think his view is more "honest" posted by John C. - Aussie on January 26, 2004 at 14:44:10:
At your urging, I looked again at my post: my first sentence sums it up: to say he is "honest" when he says he wasted three years of his life with SACD is to pick a side on this issue.I didn't take it personally and I'm not sure why you think I did, or why you think my remarks intemperate for merely stating the issue, to wit: "why is his view 'honest'"? and the followup: "If his view is 'honest' what does that make my view?"
I'm sorry, but there are sides here, and you picked one.
Finally, I stand by my previous statement regarding your comment about "old tapes"; it is with those old tapes that I fully realized the glory of the SACD format. I think the SACD transformation is greatest with the old stuff, but I recognize that others (you and others as well) disagree and I respect that view; as to the primary poster's view, heck no, I don't respect it at all!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Don't agree that I was "emotional" - Records R Black 14:59:10 01/26/04 (25)
- Re: Don't agree that I was "emotional" - regmac 15:44:49 01/26/04 (23)
- wasted years - tunenut 10:18:05 01/27/04 (0)
- Of course there's a vast right-wing conspiracy (long) - Records R Black 07:42:13 01/27/04 (21)
- Re: Of course there's a vast right-wing conspiracy (long) - regmac 11:25:33 01/27/04 (20)
- Hey, how about a friendly mention for us Christian fundamentalists as well??? - honshued 14:15:36 01/27/04 (1)
- Re: Hey, how about a friendly mention for us Christian fundamentalists as well??? - rich121 19:36:57 01/27/04 (0)
- My grasp of the obvious is complete, and you are quite the enlightened poster - Records R Black 11:48:31 01/27/04 (17)
- Re: My grasp of the obvious is complete, and you are quite the enlightened poster - regmac 12:44:34 01/27/04 (16)
- By the way, to see evidence of my "snit" toward Dalton, - Records R Black 13:51:20 01/27/04 (0)
- Catholic/Islam, did you get that right? and "no one's ears should be believed" - Records R Black 13:27:11 01/27/04 (5)
- Re: Catholic/Islam, did you get that right? and "no one's ears should be believed" - regmac 13:55:13 01/27/04 (4)
- is that your standard response whenever you are backed into a corner? - Christine Tham 18:04:36 01/27/04 (3)
- Re: is that your standard response whenever you are backed into a corner? - regmac 07:21:51 01/28/04 (2)
- Mind if I change my moniker to Solipsism or just Solipsis? nt - honshued 15:32:17 01/28/04 (0)
- "The line is applicable to anyone who writes much and says little." - tunenut 14:01:46 01/28/04 (0)
- '"mid-fi" SACD players are incapable of rendering a sonic improvement over conventional CD.' - Methos 13:24:16 01/27/04 (8)
- Re: '"mid-fi" SACD players are incapable of rendering a sonic improvement over conventional CD.' - regmac 16:05:52 01/27/04 (7)
- Oh, I don't know...can you recognise your own mother's voice, without resorting to a DBT to make certain? :-) - Methos 16:37:03 01/27/04 (6)
- Re: Oh, I don't know...can you recognise your own mother's voice, without resorting to a DBT to make certain? :-) - regmac 07:36:39 01/28/04 (5)
- Yes, I'd enjoy that, regmac...should I bring my player along, as well? - Methos 09:07:11 01/28/04 (4)
- Re: Yes, I'd enjoy that, regmac...should I bring my player along, as well? - regmac 13:55:53 01/28/04 (3)
- Not according to Stereo Review. Their panel couldn't detect the 'tighter bass' in a DBT. nt - Methos 16:30:39 01/28/04 (2)
- Re: Not according to Stereo Review. Their panel couldn't detect the 'tighter bass' in a DBT. nt - regmac 17:55:26 01/28/04 (1)
- Julian rarely admitted to hearing a difference between two components, except maybe speakers and cartridges... - Methos 15:59:19 01/29/04 (0)
- LOL. Peace returns - John C. - Aussie 15:34:36 01/26/04 (0)
You can not post to an archived thread.