In Reply to: Charles' "problem" ... posted by Christine Tham on January 3, 2006 at 13:07:25:
Since you insist on continuing to miss the points I've made in previous posts, I will just cut and paste from them to save time.Christine wrote, "the HDCD decoded output [from Mike Oldfield's Amarok] (without Peak Extend) is different from the bits on the disc."
From my post of two days ago:
http://www.audioasylum.com/forums/dvda/messages/24790.html
"Assuming that WMP behaves like the stand-alone HDCD decoders, dither will be added to at least the LSB."
From my post of December 24:
http://www.audioasylum.com/forums/dvda/messages/24706.html
"Unless an HDCD disc was recorded with 'peak extend' and/or 'low level extension', there is nothing for an HDCD playback machine to decode."
Unless you can show that WMP doesn't add dither (unlike all stand-alone implementations of HDCD) and also prove that the Mike Oldfield disk was mastered without the use of "low level extension", then your file comparison shows nothing.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- A new way to save time - Charles Hansen 14:46:12 01/03/06 (21)
- Re: A new way to save time - Christine Tham 15:02:41 01/03/06 (20)
- Saving more time - Charles Hansen 19:32:33 01/03/06 (19)
- Re: Saving more time - Christine Tham 20:20:43 01/03/06 (18)
- This seems so unlike you... - robert young 04:44:43 01/05/06 (13)
- Excuse me ... - Christine Tham 13:47:57 01/05/06 (1)
- See my reply to your "vanished" post...(nt) - robert young 13:50:49 01/05/06 (0)
- Even though your reply just vanished... - robert young 13:44:39 01/05/06 (10)
- See my amended reply above - Christine Tham 14:00:28 01/05/06 (9)
- As the Great Communicator once said... - robert young 14:14:12 01/05/06 (8)
- Re: As the Great Communicator once said... - Christine Tham 15:22:13 01/05/06 (7)
- I tried, but now I see the problem. - robert young 15:34:39 01/05/06 (6)
- Re: I tried, but now I see the problem. - Christine Tham 16:02:37 01/05/06 (5)
- Re: I tried, but now I see the problem. - robert young 16:19:48 01/05/06 (4)
- Re: I tried, but now I see the problem. - Christine Tham 16:52:07 01/05/06 (3)
- Re: I tried, but now I see the problem. - Martin419 03:46:55 01/06/06 (2)
- Martin, you have it a little backwards it is Charles (and now Frank) that should lighten-up and back-off. - Teresa 07:15:48 01/06/06 (1)
- Different issue, Teresa... - robert young 06:47:04 01/07/06 (0)
- Waisting more time... - Frank.. 00:01:40 01/04/06 (3)
- Tortured rationalization - Christine Tham 11:44:03 01/04/06 (2)
- You're wrong as usual - Frank.. 04:54:47 01/05/06 (1)
- Like I said, perhaps you need to spend some time with a patent lawyer (nt) - Christine Tham 13:06:19 01/05/06 (0)