In Reply to: RE: Editors should Edit posted by Jeffrey Lee on September 17, 2015 at 17:24:53:
Yes, *some* products have been heard and commented on by more than one person at S'phile. But there are *500 recs*. The overwhelming majority of 'em have NOT been auditioned (in their systems) by more than one reviewer at the mag. Take a close look at the capsule summaries. They are mostly quotes from one reviewer, sometimes mentioning JA's measurements. Obviously there ain't gonna be agreement or disagreement when only one reviewer auditions a product.
Hopefully we get some degree of "balanced" reporting from that one person. But most of the time we do NOT get multiple views of the same product in the same publication. For that we have to read multiple reviews in different publications.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Frequently? Most of the S'phile class ratings are based on one reviewer's take. - Rick W 08:04:04 09/18/15 (0)