RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch?

Critic's Corner

Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry.

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - Eldragon 08:17:25 12/10/14 (35)

Yes, reviewers ahould have a relative who can pitch. No question. But minor league OK?? - Nuit 18:49:13 12/16/14 (0)

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - Heifetz 09:08:18 12/14/14 (1)

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - bjh 13:33:56 12/14/14 (0)

My recall, hardly perfect, yet this is a perennial question, - bjh 05:33:24 12/12/14 (3)

RE: thanks (nt - Eldragon 07:29:53 12/12/14 (2)

RE: thanks (nt - bjh 11:21:58 12/12/14 (1)

RE: ;)) (nt - Eldragon 11:47:32 12/12/14 (0)

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - fantja 15:09:34 12/11/14 (0)

Your ears and brain know what you like - Frihed89 14:12:21 12/11/14 (0)

Perfect sales pitch maybe... - musetap 14:00:13 12/11/14 (0)

No - volunteer 13:03:58 12/11/14 (0)

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - hahax@verizon.net 20:48:46 12/10/14 (0)

More important... - mkuller 15:25:45 12/10/14 (1)

RE: More important... - lord addleford 15:46:05 12/10/14 (0)

"in my opinion Van Gogh was a mediocre painter." - johntoste 10:24:25 12/10/14 (5)

IThink" - Awe-d-o-file 11:16:35 12/10/14 (4)

god I hope you're right - johntoste 19:51:58 12/10/14 (3)

Yikes - Awe-d-o-file 09:59:06 12/11/14 (1)

RE: I'll tell you... - Eldragon 10:34:11 12/11/14 (0)

RE:LOL - so much... - Eldragon 08:35:33 12/11/14 (0)

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - middleground 10:09:53 12/10/14 (0)

By their fruits ye shall know them... . - John Marks 09:12:02 12/10/14 (13)

RE: By their fruits ye shall know them... . - stehno 02:53:01 12/13/14 (2)

I am sorry that you totally misunderstood what I wrote. - John Marks 16:58:05 12/14/14 (1)

RE: I am sorry that you totally misunderstood what I wrote. - stehno 17:23:11 12/14/14 (0)

Yes, perfect pitch is a nonsense in a tempered pitch context. - Timbo in Oz 12:13:02 12/10/14 (0)

I think that audio reviewers should be judged by the usefulness of their writing. Period. - Awe-d-o-file 11:48:07 12/10/14 (2)

Then I think that we both agree with Beau Brummel... . - John Marks 14:50:18 12/10/14 (1)

Agreed - Awe-d-o-file 09:57:04 12/11/14 (0)

RE: By their fruits ye shall know them... . - regmac 11:11:46 12/10/14 (0)

RE: By their fruits ye shall know them... . - middleground 10:11:32 12/10/14 (0)

RE: By their fruits ye shall know them... . - John Atkinson 09:55:30 12/10/14 (3)

John, see above, and thank you! - Timbo in Oz 12:25:42 12/10/14 (1)

I think that all keyboard music at least to the end of Brahms works with the Bach-Spiral temperament - John Marks 18:00:20 12/10/14 (0)

RE: By their fruits ye shall know them... . - middleground 10:12:39 12/10/14 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: Should reviewers have a Perfect, or at least Relative pitch? - hahax@verizon.net 20:48:46 12/10/14 (0)

Post a Message!