Critic's Corner

Posted by hikejohn (A) on May 12, 2008 at 18:30:38

In Reply to: RE: TAS Golden Ear Awards posted by elliot@frontrowtheater.com on May 10, 2008 at 07:26:52

I agree with you...from having been in the retail and manufacturing hifi from years ago....publications seem to have variable standards...that is why I prefer reviews that at least have some measurements versus 100% verbal comment...which while possibly valuable...makes for too many moving parts...but I recently have been criticized for making what I thought were similar points...

John

• No, you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - John Marks 09:07:22 05/13/08 (30)
  • RE: No, you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - moose 14:17:36 07/27/08 (1)
    • RE: No, you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - lord addleford 19:43:22 07/27/08 (0)
  • In advertising supported magazines the purpose of reviewers is: Get excited about new toys & entertain readers - Richard BassNut Greene 08:25:34 05/14/08 (2)
    • And the purpose of your trolling posts, Mr. Nut? (nt) - mkuller 14:43:09 05/14/08 (0)
    • You're slipping, surely you meant to say that... - rick_m 08:44:07 05/14/08 (0)
  • RE: No, you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - zako 12:31:36 05/13/08 (0)
  • RE: No, you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - hikejohn 12:22:27 05/13/08 (23)
    • Again: you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - John Marks 12:48:20 05/13/08 (22)
      • "Again: you defamed people" ........ "Dear Mr. Passive Aggressive" = you're quite the jokester! - Richard BassNut Greene 08:35:01 05/14/08 (0)
      • RE: Again: you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - hikejohn 13:54:58 05/13/08 (20)
        • RE: Again: you defamed people--you called them incompetent and corrupt - hikejohn 19:25:49 05/13/08 (0)
        • Oh, C'mon... - J. Potis 14:43:56 05/13/08 (18)
          • Hikejohn's original post - JNS 07:45:44 05/14/08 (13)
            • The post does have a problem - lancelot 10:28:30 05/16/08 (6)
              • RE: The post does have a problem - Maric 20:32:32 05/16/08 (5)
                • RE: The post does have a problem - Pat D 03:21:57 05/18/08 (4)
                  • nice to be beyond all that, isn't it Pat? (nt) - robert young 12:32:19 05/18/08 (3)
                    • I beg your pardon! - Pat D 14:00:28 05/18/08 (2)
                      • Dear Pat, YOU didn't claim it, I claimed it for you! - robert young 14:05:36 05/18/08 (1)
                        • Yep. you've now stated it more generally. - Pat D 16:03:11 05/20/08 (0)
            • RE: Hikejohn's original post - Maric 20:58:34 05/14/08 (2)
              • Excellent post! - JNS 07:58:05 05/15/08 (1)
                • Disagree...which should be allowed, no? - robert young 06:16:12 05/17/08 (0)
            • RE: Hikejohn's original post - J. Potis 14:25:33 05/14/08 (2)
              • RE: Hikejohn's original post - hikejohn 09:45:58 05/15/08 (0)
              • RE: Hikejohn's original post - JNS 08:54:27 05/15/08 (0)
          • RE: Oh, C'mon... - hikejohn 15:17:59 05/13/08 (3)
            • RE: Oh, C'mon... - hikejohn 19:53:33 05/13/08 (2)
              • I am sure Mr. Atkinson will sleep better with that knowledge. - Bruce Kendall 11:53:52 05/14/08 (0)
              • Maybe you ought to... - robert young 06:21:23 05/14/08 (0)

Post a Followup:

---

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] Thread: [ Display  All  Email ] [ Critic's Corner ]
[ Comment ] [ Edit ] [ Delete ] [ Copyright Warning! Click for Details ]

---

[ Top of Page ] [ Contact Us ] [ Support/Wish List ] [ Copyright © 2008, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]

---

[ General ] [ Speakers ] [ Tubes ] [ Vinyl ] [ Digital ] [ Hi-Rez ] [ Video Asylum ] [ Cables ] [ Tweaks/DIY ] [ Music ] [ Films ]

---