Eggs Ackley... - mkuller - Critic's Corner

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - hexenboden 17:15:24 03/26/06 (147)

more negative reviews - kbuzz 17:55:22 04/13/06 (0)

Speaker distortion curves - Atexanathome 09:43:50 04/07/06 (0)

Cary CAD 500 MB's and a comparison between nuforce and chanel island "D" amps - Shane from AUS 03:25:31 04/02/06 (0)

Coverage of vintage gear, more content for the entry level - McGruder 05:43:15 04/01/06 (0)

Lirpa turntable and electronics . . . * - mr grits 17:51:13 03/31/06 (0)

What I would like to see - more comparisons... - mkuller 14:15:31 03/29/06 (19)

Re: shoot outs, and gear list - hifimercer 15:43:51 03/30/06 (0)

Good post -- great suggestions for Stereophile (or Absolute Sound) - Richard BassNut Greene 07:35:09 03/30/06 (4)

Re: Good post -- great suggestions for Stereophile (or Absolute Sound) - hifimercer 15:55:38 03/30/06 (3)

Re: Good post -- great suggestions for Stereophile (or Absolute Sound) - jim@signalpath 07:05:24 04/03/06 (0)

Re: Good post -- great suggestions for Stereophile... - John Atkinson 04:01:43 03/31/06 (1)

Re: Stereophile's on top of it - hifimercer 16:05:23 03/31/06 (0)

The "Follow Up"s are great... - hexenboden 17:47:26 03/29/06 (12)

well, hex - Bruce from DC 07:09:57 03/30/06 (11)

Point taken... - hexenboden 17:05:26 03/30/06 (1)

Re: agreed - Bruce from DC 07:58:17 03/31/06 (0)

Eggs Ackley... - mkuller 10:58:27 03/30/06 (8)

Re: Eggs Ackley... - John Atkinson 13:12:54 03/30/06 (0)

Which reminds me....... - bwkendall 11:42:24 03/30/06 (6)

Well, I wuz gonna whine - Bruce from DC 13:52:02 03/30/06 (5)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - regmac 07:11:39 03/31/06 (3)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - Bruce from DC 07:33:25 03/31/06 (2)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - regmac 12:44:49 03/31/06 (1)

Re: "abruptly changed to subject to politics" - Bruce from DC 13:05:10 03/31/06 (0)

This is the first year I've had anything that was on the list. - bwkendall 14:15:25 03/30/06 (0)

Re: Pam Andersons torso... - HiFiOd 10:10:01 03/29/06 (1)

Amplifier Party Torture Test To End All Tests - nightdoggy 10:48:03 03/29/06 (0)

This one requires no deep thought ... an updated GKer ... Black Cube 2006! nt - bjh 08:50:16 03/29/06 (0)

How about a reviewer shootout? - Presto 19:59:46 03/28/06 (2)

Something like the old battle of the network stars - Kloss 07:48:14 03/29/06 (0)

How about a DBT of Bose 901 vs Vandersteen 5A? :-) (nt) - andy_c 20:18:25 03/28/06 (0)

SACD modded vs high buck players - Ozzie 18:35:59 03/28/06 (2)

Who would decide what was correctly modded - awsmone 05:05:17 03/29/06 (1)

Re: Who would decide what was correctly modded - Ozzie 17:09:39 03/29/06 (0)

Re: Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - wadiaguy 11:05:16 03/28/06 (7)

Re: Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - McGruder 05:38:12 04/01/06 (0)

IIRC, they published floor plans years ago; needs an update. nt - markrohr 11:35:52 03/29/06 (0)

Superb idea! - robert young 08:58:15 03/29/06 (0)

reviewers rooms - awsmone 05:13:29 03/29/06 (0)

You hit it right on the nail... - hexenboden 05:11:18 03/29/06 (2)

Floor plan, Rives design, and JA's listening comments, in April issue - John Marks 18:52:12 03/30/06 (1)

Amen - hexenboden 10:37:40 03/31/06 (0)

Re: Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - chris keating 07:00:19 03/28/06 (0)

ASR and Cayin - Amerigo 03:05:02 03/28/06 (0)

Cool, a wish list! - Enophile 17:50:09 03/27/06 (0)

A turntable shoot-out... - robert young 16:02:02 03/27/06 (0)

The new JBL Array Series nt. - Robert Hamel 15:21:29 03/27/06 (6)

An amazing amount of speakers by JBL - delaney@rea-alp.com 08:38:51 03/29/06 (0)

Any website on this? (nT) - hexenboden 19:04:17 03/27/06 (4)

Sure JBL - Robert Hamel 19:45:42 03/27/06 (3)

Are those really arrays? - hexenboden 19:53:37 03/27/06 (2)

No that's what they call the series nt. - Robert Hamel 21:23:53 03/27/06 (1)

Re: No that's what they call the series nt. - Gulliver 22:14:47 03/28/06 (0)

Audio Research CD3 MkII (nt) - JohnL 15:19:22 03/27/06 (0)

Any Vandersteen speakers (no reviews since 2000 -- that's like an auto magazine ignoring Ford products for six years) - Richard BassNut Greene 09:26:45 03/27/06 (87)

Re: Any Vandersteen speakers (no reviews since 2000 -- that's like an auto magazine ignoring Ford products for six year - Norm Strong 16:12:49 03/27/06 (13)

I'd define "high-end" based on where they are sold and where they are advertised, more than the price. - Richard BassNut Greene 07:43:27 03/29/06 (12)

Re: I'd define "high-end" based on where they are sold and where they are advertised, more than the price. - jimmycj 11:31:54 04/02/06 (0)

You should take a pause from your - bjh 08:47:46 03/29/06 (10)

Many British magazines actually give good and bad ratings to products - Richard BassNut Greene 09:10:05 03/29/06 (9)

Well then follow the advice in the British magazines! ... - bjh 09:29:43 03/29/06 (8)

I do ... but that doesn't mean I can't encourage American magazines to be pro-consumer - Richard BassNut Greene 14:05:56 03/30/06 (7)

Work on being Pro-Hobby first! - bjh 20:42:37 03/30/06 (6)

I'm Pro-Hobby by reminding audiophiles that all components do not sound different -- that can be an expensive fantasy - Richard BassNut Greene 07:55:53 03/31/06 (5)

From a guy who's system has encouraged him to discard 100s (?) of CDs due to *bad* sound I say ... bla-bla-bla, BS! nt - bjh 11:21:22 03/31/06 (4)

I refuse to tolerate poor recordings -- but you love them -- I guess we disagree again - Richard BassNut Greene 08:12:05 04/03/06 (3)

I'm sorry, RBNG, but where... - robert young 20:48:57 04/04/06 (2)

Some musicians will tolerate poor recordings and still enjoy "good performances" - Richard BassNut Greene 09:00:37 04/06/06 (1)

Sorry! But if you find youself discarding 100s of CDs, - bjh 10:06:26 04/06/06 (0)

How many times can one man fail to understand the philosophy of the magazine? -t - Sordidman 15:47:58 03/27/06 (30)

Why don't you tell us the philosophy of the magazine? - Richard BassNut Greene 08:55:57 03/28/06 (24)

Well... - jamesgarvin 12:47:55 03/28/06 (20)

What's your problem? - nightdoggy 07:34:18 03/29/06 (1)

Re: What's your problem? - jamesgarvin 08:27:07 03/29/06 (0)

Why not post your own opinion? .... It's so easy to criticize others, but what value does that add to this forum? (nt) - Richard BassNut Greene 07:23:34 03/29/06 (17)

Re: Why not post your own opinion? .... It's so easy to criticize others, but what value does that add to this forum? - jamesgarvin 08:43:13 03/29/06 (16)

I subscribed to Stereophile when there was no advertising and the editor didn't offer only "Happy Face" reviews - Richard BassNut Greene 08:57:55 03/29/06 (15)

Re: I subscribed to Stereophile when there was no advertising and the editor didn't offer only "Happy Face" reviews - jamesgarvin 12:26:28 03/29/06 (4)

I wrote that Stereophile is similar to other advertising-supported magazines -- I didn't say they were "on the take" - Richard BassNut Greene 07:30:39 03/30/06 (3)

Re: I wrote that Stereophile is similar to other advertising-supported magazines -- I didn't say they were "on the take" - jamesgarvin 08:56:47 03/30/06 (2)

I guess in your mind advertising has no effect on consumers and no effect on advertising supported businesses - Richard BassNut Greene 14:46:57 03/30/06 (1)

Re: I guess in your mind advertising has no effect on consumers and no effect on advertising supported businesses - jamesgarvin 15:42:17 03/30/06 (0)

Every item reviewed is GOOD - Sordidman 11:48:18 03/29/06 (9)

"Stereophile doesn't review components that are bad" = poor excuse for so many Happy Face reviews - Richard BassNut Greene 07:49:14 03/30/06 (8)

Your meanspirited sarcasm aside, - "performance" is relative - Sordidman 09:45:36 03/30/06 (0)

Re: "Stereophile doesn't review components that are bad" = poor excuse for so many Happy Face reviews - jamesgarvin 08:53:43 03/30/06 (6)

Two different speakers in two different rooms fed by different electronics? - Richard BassNut Greene 14:41:41 03/30/06 (4)

Because there are many different definitions of "good performance" -t - Sordidman 15:41:56 03/30/06 (0)

The difficulty with the "performance per dollar" ratio... - robert young 14:55:55 03/30/06 (2)

If Consumers Reports can have "Best Buys" and British magazines have 1 to 5 star ratings for audio products ............ - Richard BassNut Greene 08:10:04 03/31/06 (1)

Either you really don't read the posts you respond to.. - robert young 08:15:00 03/31/06 (0)

Great point -t - Sordidman 09:46:24 03/30/06 (0)

You couldn't be more wrong, and you're not even close... - Sordidman 12:19:22 03/28/06 (2)

As I wrote in my prior post -- please give your own opinion - Richard BassNut Greene 07:18:40 03/29/06 (1)

It's Stereophiles: the answer has been given in April 05 - Sordidman 09:43:34 03/29/06 (0)

Great ... - bjh 18:16:24 03/27/06 (1)

Sorry.......... - Sordidman 12:23:54 03/28/06 (0)

I'm not sure a number is possible... - robert young 15:56:13 03/27/06 (2)

That character attack was almost funny -- keep working on your comedy writing and in a few years ... - Richard BassNut Greene 08:58:24 03/28/06 (1)

Funny? I was being serious. - robert young 04:34:09 03/29/06 (0)

Give it a rest, Mr. Greene. Didn't you read below... - robert young 09:44:36 03/27/06 (41)

Some thoughts - John Atkinson 16:01:54 03/27/06 (40)

Logic and honesty, what a nice combination - Craiger56@aol.com 19:07:55 03/29/06 (0)

Is the BassNut right? - Ozzie 18:45:17 03/28/06 (4)

Please don't put words in my mouth - John Atkinson 08:16:22 03/29/06 (3)

Your words, my quotes. - Ozzie 17:34:03 03/29/06 (2)

Re: Your words, my quotes. - muser 15:53:46 03/31/06 (0)

Actually I'm not sure... - RGA 04:30:50 03/30/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - Bruce from DC 13:59:48 03/28/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - jamesgarvin 08:58:04 03/28/06 (21)

Re: Some thoughts - John Atkinson 10:30:23 03/28/06 (20)

Yeah, but - Rufipennis 11:29:47 03/28/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - jamesgarvin 11:14:17 03/28/06 (18)

Well yeah... - RGA 02:50:52 03/29/06 (3)

Or maybe . . . - Pat D 05:30:57 04/11/06 (2)

Re: Or maybe . . . - RGA 02:23:52 04/15/06 (1)

Re: Or maybe . . . - Pat D 09:49:48 04/19/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - Jay 12:57:07 03/28/06 (13)

Oh! I suppose you figure all we innocents ... - bjh 17:09:07 03/28/06 (1)

Re: "Oh! I suppose you figure all we innocents ... - Jay 06:48:11 03/29/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - jamesgarvin 13:38:14 03/28/06 (10)

I think your speculation is right - Rufipennis 14:46:50 03/28/06 (7)

How many folks buy speakers based on JAs measurements? - Sordidman 16:59:26 03/28/06 (6)

Re: How many folks buy speakers based on JAs measurements? - Pat D 05:44:06 04/11/06 (0)

The measurements are great, but... - hexenboden 21:10:03 03/29/06 (1)

Re: The measurements are great, but... - Pat D 05:53:35 04/11/06 (0)

Not so sure in this case - Rufipennis 06:14:34 03/29/06 (2)

I'm not trying to criticize Vandersteen speakers or their motivations - Sordidman 16:18:36 03/29/06 (1)

Re: I'm not trying to criticize Vandersteen speakers or their motivations - misterears 13:17:16 03/31/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - Jay 14:05:17 03/28/06 (1)

You need to read a little more closely - jamesgarvin 16:08:18 03/28/06 (0)

Thanks you for responding in detail about Vandersteen speakers - Richard BassNut Greene 08:39:42 03/28/06 (1)

Re: Thanks you for responding in detail about Vandersteen speakers - Ozzie 18:53:07 03/28/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - jim@signalpath 06:32:43 03/28/06 (0)

You see what you just wrote -- means to me that... - RGA 04:52:20 03/28/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - morricab 01:30:42 03/28/06 (0)

Sorry but this stinks... - hexenboden 18:58:19 03/27/06 (0)

Re: Some thoughts - TomLarson 17:13:55 03/27/06 (0)

Let's see if Mr. Greene... - robert young 16:05:39 03/27/06 (3)

You meant Mr. Nut, right? -t - bwkendall 18:08:46 03/27/06 (2)

Mr. Young and Mr. Kendall -- you forgot to include any words about audio in your posts -- perhaps an inadvertent error ? - Richard BassNut Greene 08:46:21 03/28/06 (1)

Sometimes I prefer to read and learn from... - robert young 04:04:17 03/29/06 (0)

Have they reviewed - bjh 08:50:28 03/27/06 (0)

Re: Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - Scott_N 08:19:00 03/27/06 (0)

Re: Stereophile Reviews (and measurements) you would like to see.. - Dave Pogue 05:04:20 03/27/06 (2)

a regular group of afforodable gear - hifitommy 06:33:45 03/27/06 (1)

Re: a regular group of afforodable gear - porziob@aol.com 07:27:59 03/27/06 (0)

Follow Ups

Eggs Ackley... - mkuller 10:58:27 03/30/06 (8)

Re: Eggs Ackley... - John Atkinson 13:12:54 03/30/06 (0)

Which reminds me....... - bwkendall 11:42:24 03/30/06 (6)

Well, I wuz gonna whine - Bruce from DC 13:52:02 03/30/06 (5)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - regmac 07:11:39 03/31/06 (3)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - Bruce from DC 07:33:25 03/31/06 (2)

Re: Well, I wuz gonna whine - regmac 12:44:49 03/31/06 (1)

Re: "abruptly changed to subject to politics" - Bruce from DC 13:05:10 03/31/06 (0)

This is the first year I've had anything that was on the list. - bwkendall 14:15:25 03/30/06 (0)