High Efficiency Speaker Asylum

Need speakers that can rock with just one watt? You found da place.

Return to High Efficiency Speaker Asylum


Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?

68.211.12.116

Posted on September 18, 2009 at 18:25:29
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Hello,

Am I delusional to think a 12.5' x 14' room (a spare bedroom) would work OK for Altec 19's? Please help me stay out of trouble :>).

My listening is low volumn primarily acoustical (jazz, chamber) in the evenings after the rest of the family has turned in. Someday I'd like to move them out to the living room but for now its the spare rooom.

Will they work OK near field?

I have an opportunity to purchase a pair locally.

Thanks,

MJ

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on October 31, 2009 at 19:49:53
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
No luck finding decent 19's in my budget but have found a nice pair of Carmel's for $900. Orginal owner from early 60's. Never messed with. 414z, 806/811.

Perhaps if they prove too big for my space I will build some 614 cab's (for one of the 414's) and place the horns on top....like JE Labs.

Am I heading in the right direction or should I continue to wait for 19's? Low level listening, 300B SET power amps, 13' x 15' room.

Mark

Japanese bookshelf speakers, posted on September 23, 2009 at 12:48:18
Peter H-son
Audiophile

Posts: 1403
Joined: October 17, 2007
That JBL called the 4350.

A Korean audiophile with 2 pair and large enough room.

I do not consider the Altec 19 or, say, Tannoy GRF large. The reason for that is that they don't go very deep. The room acoustics will make sure they go more than deep enough. They are very suitable for small rooms.

"Is any sick among you? let him call for the elders of the church; and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord: And the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord shall raise him up"
--James 5:14-15

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 23, 2009 at 08:00:28
sonic_boom
Audiophile

Posts: 1
Location: NY
Joined: August 24, 2005
I believe the 19's are controlled directivity (CD) speakers and for that reason alone they are going to be good in a small room. For CD speakers, the bigger the better. Just don't forget to toe them quite a bit - around 45deg, or at least so that their axis crosses in front of your listening position.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 21, 2009 at 18:16:36
Bikeryder
Audiophile

Posts: 35
Location: MontrealWest
Joined: March 27, 2006
Get them, I use A7s in a 20*14 room.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 21, 2009 at 15:11:59
joaquin.chile
Audiophile

Posts: 4
Location: Viña del Mar
Joined: September 19, 2009
Hello all, first post here , im from Chile .

I have used my 19 in both , a very small room (bedroom) and in my living room , the living room being not big as well .
IMHO it depends on the rest of the gear you have . Particulary power cords , and conditioners and amp , if they are good enough that horn will resonate because of the high energy delivered to the 802 8G driver . So always watch for the H811B horn , its not designed for home , it sounds a lot better in theaters ( dont know why A.L put this horn in the 19 )
After 2 years and several upgrades thats my conclussion . So even though i love the 416 8B woofer and the 802 8G , im considering trying a fiber glass horn or a wooden one .

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 21, 2009 at 16:29:00
joaquin.chile
Audiophile

Posts: 4
Location: Viña del Mar
Joined: September 19, 2009
I would recomend a 604 duplex , (the 604 8H) for near field .

These are great speakers, large room or small, posted on September 20, 2009 at 06:29:27
travisty
Audiophile

Posts: 547
Location: Tokyo
Joined: April 2, 2003
I have mine in a room which is probably just a couple of feet larger in each direction, and they sound awesome. I second, or third, or whatever the vinyl and SET idea for upstream.

Watch out for the bass reverb in the corners behind you. The idea of putting a set of shelves behind you against the wall is a good one.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 18:53:08
makarushka
Audiophile

Posts: 83
Location: Oakland, CA
Joined: April 29, 2003
I do not have Model 19 but my Altec Valencias 846B use the same components and their crossovers have been modded to the same crossover point as the 19, so I believe some of my experience may be relevant if not translate directly. I have used them for a few months extensively before the modifications, too. Most of the below applies to both.

I have them in a room much like yours in terms of size, albeit with low slanted ceilings -- something that helps a lot in this small room.

Here's what I can state based on my experience (and preferences) -- and a lot of it simply concurs with the experience of others in this thread: I do not have a problem with them in a room this size and enjoy them tremendously, experiencing a coherent wall of sound, as long as the system has been optimized as follows:

- you sit at least 7 feet away from them
- the speakers are spaced apart at least 6 feet
- they are toed in nearly or exactly 45 degrees, pointing right at your ears
- they are RAISED off the floor so your ears are at a level of the point exactly between the horn and the woofer's edge
- you control the amount of bass coupling by the material of the stands; in my case there was too much boom, so instead of solid heavy stands i had first, I got a pair of two IKEA carts (forget the model, can look up) that have these rubber casters and put the speakers on that. Also bitumen dots in between the speaker and the top surface of the cart. This took off the boom and optimized the sound in my room. The speakers's vertical position was crucial to me, however, as otherwise the system sounded "low" and darker, and I hate that.

This is without going into other mods that can be done (and I believe are worthwhile IME) -- some will consider modding anything on these a sacrilege, and I would not argue. But I myself am all for smart modifications, especially when it comes to aged components that do age badly. One modification that I learned and tried on several box speakers that used to have old fiberglass involves replacing it with small bubblewrap on three sides glued to the walls with 3M 77 adhesive, a square sheet of carpet felt the size of the woofer right behind it, and, of all things, styrofoam peanuts on the bottom -- to taste, and in a mesh bag from the grapefruits in a grocery store if need be. This sounded ridiculous to me when I first heard it, and still does when I type it but it works amazingly well. The general perceived effect is that of much cleaner sound all around and a extra octave of bass. I was advised of this by Don Allen but apparently this was the idea of a guy who designed the hammer dynamics speakers...

Hope it helps...

Oh, and to my taste, a 45 SET is NOT enough for these for all music. 2A3 does better but even then a step up in power in the form of a 300B SET or a 47 pushpull works much better to my taste. Also work very well with various EL84 PP of which I am a great fan, and McIntosh MC225 -- also a wonderful match; that amp is great in general on horn-based efficient speakers I think.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 06:25:12
cids
Audiophile

Posts: 364
Joined: April 20, 2002
Yes, it will work just fine but watch out the standing wave.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 06:38:30
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Hi Cids! Thanks!

I see from your Inmates Systems entry that you have a room about the same size as mine. I'd be gratefull for advice on setting the 19s up. Long wall or short wall? How would you locate treatment (panels)...what material did you use? Etc.

Appreciatively,

Mark

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 09:20:15
cids
Audiophile

Posts: 364
Joined: April 20, 2002
Yes, my horn speakers are really big.

My advices:
You should place the Altec 19 on the 12ft. side.
In order to minimize the effect of standing wave, you should toe-in your speakers(45 degree with be the most effective).
Also place a huge Ikea LP rack....I think it is called Expedit behind your listening position. Leave some empty slot open and fill the rest with LPs or other items to create a mixture of absorption/reflection surface.
Some absorption panel between the wall of the speakers and the back wall behind the Expedit.

Get yourself a nice 45 or 2A3 SET and use vinyl as source.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:18:03
George S. Roland
Audiophile

Posts: 361
Location: N W Pennsylvania
Joined: March 20, 2004
These are such wonderful speakers, that I think, if you love that sound, you should go for it. Try them on the long wall if the space permits it, relax and enjoy one of the best domestic loudspeakers around! I love mine!

George Roland

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 06:43:53
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Thanks George,

Long wall placement would sure help me work around existing furniture in the room. Why would it be better for sonics? Curious.

Mark

Just think of them as really big headphones....., posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:13:40
doodlebug
Audiophile

Posts: 1740
Location: Little Rock, Arkansas
Joined: July 27, 2006
and you'll be fine. Actually, I've heard a set in that size room and they weren't bad at all. The key, though, is to keep yourself in the right position. They'll throw a larger soundstage in a larger room.

The good news is that you can find a nice, low power amp to drive them.....

Cheers,

David

RE: Just think of them as really big headphones....., posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:31:48
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Hey Dave,

I'm getting pretty stoked! I recently picked up an old pair of DIY 300b SET monoblock power amps and a Melos SHA-1 headphone amp that can be used as a preamp.

Thanks to all for your kind help.

Mark

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:02:43
I've had Bozak 302's, Bozak 4000 lowboys,AR LST's,EV Esquires,EV Regencys and Altec Flamencos and most were in rooms no bigger than 12X12 at one time or another and I never thought a small room was a problem with any of them.

Non of the above were quite right but I got a sense that BIG and efficient was what I really wanted so I got a pair of Altec Model 19's and they are in an 11.5 X 11.5 room on the second floor of my 1 1/2 story house where the front and back ceilings of the room are slanted because of the the roofline.

The speakers are on a wall under the slanted ceiling with one at each end near the side wallss and they are toed in for almost but not quite on axis listening.

My search for loudspeakers has finally ended and the only drawback, if it is one, is that the "sweetspot" is very narrow in the small room but being the only listener 99% of the time, I'm always seated in the sweetspot and I never had a complaint about imaging. But I'm not super critical about imaging if what I hear sounds like real voice and real instruments.

On mono the image is dead center like there's a big speaker in the center and the Model 19's at each side vanish. Kind of creepy how they do that.
With good stereo recordings (LP's) there's a center image,left,right and front to back imaging.

True you can't play them too loud or you'll pop your ears but the big wall of sound more than compensates for lower listening levels for me.

I've heard my 19's sound all kinds of different ways using different equipment/turntables/cartridges and I prefer vintage Mac tube equipment with them although it's remarkable what a Scott 299(a) with GE 7189A outputs can do with them.

I don't know if I'm lucky or if the slanted ceilings help but there's no bass boom or nodes that rear their ugly heads and it makes me wonder why so many people seem to have problems with things like that.
The Flamenco A's drove me nuts with the one note boom bass in that room and a much larger room but I chalked that up to the higher tuning.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:18:48
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Wow Dave. Very helpfull. Thanks.

My listening is low level. I think I'm going to go for it.

Mark

Your welcome, posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:28:58
By the way,I got my 19's a couple of years ago just West of Atlanta. I figured I had to get them then or I'd be waiting a long time to find another almost local pair I could pick up with a rental truck.

It was a 2 1/2 hour trip each way from Aiken, SC and $325 for the truck plus gas but well worth it to me because it ended my speaker search.

I had been following Tom Brennans posts for years on the Asylum and I agreed with him 99.8% of the time and his comments on the 19's "made me do it." Thanks Tom.

RE: Your welcome, posted on September 18, 2009 at 20:35:09
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
I'll be driving to Nashville to get mine. Arrrgh....I wish I could find some closer to home (Atlanta!).

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 19:38:13
Tom Brennan
Audiophile

Posts: 5056
Joined: January 2, 2000
I used my 19s in a 12'x14' room that I used as a movie room and they sounded fine, Hell, they sounded great. "Integration", imaging and tone were excellent.

Might they have sounded better in a bigger room? Probably but so what? I used them in the room available for their intended use. They sure as Hell sounded better than the Altec 605s and KRK ST-6s that I also used in the same room.


Photobucket

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on October 31, 2009 at 19:57:02
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Tom,

I have had no luck finding decent 19's in my budget but have found a nice pair of Carmels for $900. Orginal owner from early 60's. Never messed with. 414z, 806/811.

I think you have had experience with both the Carmels and 19's.

Am I heading in the right direction or should I continue to wait for 19's? Low level listening, 300B SET power amps, 13' x 15' room.

Perhaps if the Carmels prove too big for my space I will build some 614 cab's (for one of the 414's) and place the horns on top....like JE Labs.


Mark

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 19:50:22
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Thanks Tom. Thats a confidence boost. BTW...are you missing yours?

Mark

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 19:09:09
Plinko
Audiophile

Posts: 1359
Location: N East, USA
Joined: July 21, 2005
I think there are some posts by njjohn over in the SET asylum on his enjoyment of the 19s in nearfield.

I think it can work but only at low levels otherwise, they'll blow your head off. Might not get the best soundstaging out of the deal (then again, mine seem to soundstage pretty well). Otherwise, bide your time until you can get them in a larger space.

Btw, I just popped in some restored (not modded) crossovers in my 19s this evening and the sound is remarkable. "End of the road" speaker for me.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 19:29:05
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Plinko,

Thanks! Who restored your crossovers?

Mark

P.S. Do you have yours in a large room?

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 18, 2009 at 22:03:32
Plinko
Audiophile

Posts: 1359
Location: N East, USA
Joined: July 21, 2005
Just picked up the crossovers today from Hot Glass Audio (Ryan Inman).

The old electrolytics in these crossovers will need replaced. I kept the inductors, however, as some indicated that it would preserve the warm (or, not bright) sound.

I dunno why I waited so long. The warmth has been kept but they now sound a lot faster with much better bass. These are exactly the improvements I was hoping for.

My room (basement) is approx 16' X 19' and using a 300B and a 45/46 amp with these.

Now that I think more about it, don't hesitate if you can pick them up yourself. I had mine shipped nearly 3,000 miles because I got tired of waiting.

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 06:30:56
Posts: 20
Location: Atlanta
Joined: March 24, 2008
Hi Plinko,

Thanks!

What potential issues should I be on the lookout for? I hope to see the 19's next week.

Perhaps:

1- Integrity of the box? I gather that the joints can open up if they have been water damaged.
2 - Crossover caps leaking.
3- The seller states "811b Sectoral Mid/High Frequency Horn Featuring the patented Orange Radial Phase Plug". How can I verify that the compression drives have the Tangerine plugs? Do all the 811b's come with this design?
4- Apparently the 19's where produced with a variety of woofers...which ones are considered best?

Thanks agian. Keeping my fingers crossed this works out!

Mark

RE: Altec 19 components, posted on September 19, 2009 at 18:44:35
Tom Brennan
Audiophile

Posts: 5056
Joined: January 2, 2000
Early 19s used the 802-G compression driver on the 811B horn for treble and the 416B woofer. Both drivers used Alnico magnets, for what that's worth. The 802-G in the 19 was a plain black bodied driver with a paper part sticker but no model badge, at least as far as I know.

Later 19s used the ferrite magnet 902 compression driver and 416C woofer. Never heard a 19 with a 416C but I have heard 19s with the 902-Bs and there's no difference in the sound I can tell.

In any event it's the crossover of the 19 that's the dealmaker, the compensation of the network extended the highs farther than previous Altecs, also the 1200hz crossover point is important to the speaker's imaging (and power handling too no doubt).

RE: Altec 19 in a small room? Am I kidding myself?, posted on September 19, 2009 at 16:05:19
Coner
Industry Professional

Posts: 828
Joined: November 17, 2001
I plan on building some, though they may not look like a 19, will
have same components and cab vol. I have the parts sitting here
except the x-over, so will most likely bi-amp.

Yes, I think all 19's use the 902 tangerine driver, either
802's or 902's are good. Check in person or pic to verify that.

I thought the 19's all used 416's, maybe the difference being
416B's. or 416C model. Either is good. I have the Alnico B's.




30" is a woofer size (EV 30W)

Page processed in 0.229 seconds.