Room Acoustics Forum by Rives Audio

Welcome! Need support, you got it. Or share you ideas and experiences.

Return to Room Acoustics Forum by Rives Audio

Room Acoustics Forum by Rives Audio

Re: First Reflection Point Formula

12.107.18.54

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display All Email ] [ Room Acoustics Forum by Rives Audio ]

clio09

(A)

In Reply to: Re: First Reflection Point Formula posted by David Aiken on May 13, 2006 at 23:01:28:

Thanks for the clarification. It all makes perfect sense now. I did run across the original site I was referring to and the formula posted there. You can follow the link to it.
In this calculation (click on the picture) it appears the critical point is the distance from the listening position to the side wall. Once the result is derived from the formula the point is moved forward from this position, not from the speaker to wall position as in your formula. In your formula the distance is 1.75 from the speaker to wall point, here I get 1.62 from the listening position to wall point. They end up being two different locations. Do you have any thoughts on this?

Formula (Open in New Window)

Follow Ups:

Re: First Reflection Point Formula - David Aiken 14:07:10 05/14/06 (3)
I haven't seen that formula before.
The big difference between results is that Ethan's formula calculates a position along the wall from a point level with the listener. Mine calculates along the wall from a point level with the speaker.
Both formulas give the same point on the wall. Mine will give you 1.25 ft forward of the speaker plane using Ethan's example. His formula gives you 3.75 feet forward of the plane of the listening position. The distance between the 2 planes is 5 feet, which is 1.25' plus 3.75'.
So both formulae give you the identical point. Choose whichever is easier for you.
David Aiken
- What am I saying?� - David Aiken 15:04:14 05/14/06 (0)
  I have seen that formula before.
  It's actually exactly the same formula as mine. Ethan has merely changed the location of my "c" (his Y) and transposed my "a" and "b" (his X1 and X2) at one point so that it's calculating from the plane of the listening position instead of the speaker plane. The calculation process in both cases is exactly the same.
  I'm slow this morning.
  David Aiken
- Re: First Reflection Point Formula - clio09 14:21:59 05/14/06 (1)
  I went ahead and used your formula. I was able to add an absorber panel for the right channel speaker. The refelction point for the left channel is in the middle of an archway that leads into the next room. So either I will have to mount the panel on a stand and place it in the archway or leave it as is. In any event thanks for your help.
  - Re: First Reflection Point Formula - David Aiken 14:44:36 05/14/06 (0)
    If the reflection point is in the middle of an archway, there's no reflection there so theoretically there's no need to use a panel at that point. The sound passes through the archway and doesn't get reflected till it hits the next wall. You could calculate the point on that wall but unless that wall is very close to the archway (say only a hallway on the other side of the arch), the wall of your room is going to block that reflection for you.
    Archways can be a little tricky, however, and you do have reflections from the room on the other side that will be difracted around the edges of the archway as they re-enter your room. You may find that placing a free standing panel so it covers the edge of the archway, overlapping a bit into the archway itself and covering a bit of the adjacent wall as well, may help things a bit. I think only experimenting will tell you whether or not you'll get some advantage.
    I have an archway beside my right speaker. The reflection point isn't in the archway but on the wall towards me. I find that covering the edge of the archway with the panel helps a bit in my room, but the geometries are different to your room and it's possible that I'm actually getting a bit of reflection from the wall on the other side of the hallway as well as the reflection from the wall inside the room. I haven't tried calculating a reflection point for the hall wall, but ensuring the panel covers about a foot of the archway certainly does help a bit.
    If you note in Ethan's diagram, he places the reflection point around the middle of the panel and when I do that with my reflection point, my panel just covers a little of the archway. I experimented a little with moving the panel sideways in both directions and discovered that moving it fractionally towards the speaker so that it covered a bit more of the archway was better. Actually, if the panel is spaced out a bit from the wall as mine are, the point at which the reflection path meets the panel will be a bit closer towards the speaker than the reflection point on the wall is, so what I've done is just centred the panel on the reflection path a bit more.
    If you're using panels on both sides, don't have them exactly opposite each other. Move one a couple of inches or so towards the speaker and the other a couple of inches towards you. You'll get a bit more benefit from doing that than having them exactly opposite each other. Varying height an inch or 2 should also help a little bit if you can.
    David Aiken

Post a Followup:

Moniker (Username):
Password (Required):	Forgot Password?
	Remember my Moniker & Password (What's this?) Eat Me
E-Mail:
Subject:

Message:	(Posts are subject to Content Rules)

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
Optional Image URL:
E-mail Replies:	Automagically notify you when someone responds.

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display All Email ] [ Room Acoustics Forum by Rives Audio ] [ Comment ] [ Delete ] [ Copyright Warning! Click for Details ]

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

The Cable Cooker