|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
206.255.211.134
In Reply to: RE: So you can somehow tell what posts I read? posted by Pat D on July 01, 2010 at 07:34:24
While the center channel for HT content is primarily used for dialogue, such is not true for music recordings. So, what then is the purpose for needing a center channel as Olive opines that does NOT pertain to "center fill"?
rw
Follow Ups:
2 speaker stereo does not have center channel. Sean's multi-channel has a center channel.
Nothing in Sean's text denies that there can be some center fill in the stereo image in 2 channel stereo. Sean likes stereo recordings better with a center channel in his multichannel system.
If you want to know in more detail why Sean Olive prefers to listen to his multichannel system, even with stereo recordings, you should ask him. I have not said whether I agree or disagree with him on that issue, or whether I think everything he recommends is practical for me personally. I am concerned with deliberate misrepresentations of what he said.
__
"Always be sincere, whether you mean it or not."---Flanders & Swann
Take two:
So, what then is the purpose for needing a center channel as Olive opines that does NOT pertain to "center fill"?
Nothing in Sean's text denies that there can be some center fill in the stereo image in 2 channel stereo...
No, that is the incorrect assumption you made that C93 mis-characterized Olive's intent.
rw
I have never denied that a center channel has something to do with center fill. Some people with multichannel systems prefer to do without a center channel, like Eysespy, and some prefer to have one, like Sean Olive.
You are now subtly change the issue to a "needing a center channel."
E-stat
"So, what then is the purpose for needing a center channel as Olive opines that does NOT pertain to "center fill"?
You are asking me to answer for Sean Olive, and you're quite right that I am refusing to do so. If you want to know what he thinks on the matter, you should ask him.
__
"Always be sincere, whether you mean it or not."---Flanders & Swann
I have never denied that a center channel has something to do with center fill.
Sure you did. That's what started the conversation. Here, let's review your comments again:
-no center channel = no center fill NOT!
Either a center channel has something to do with center fill or it does not. Olive found his center fill lacking in two channel and *boosted* it by adding another speaker. What else would you do with one? Like Tony, I'm done.
rw
Maybe you can begin to understand that when they appointed you to be a moderator at Audio Review, I decided to severely cut back my participation there.
__
"Always be sincere, whether you mean it or not."---Flanders & Swann
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: