|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
206.255.203.68
In Reply to: RE: Boston Audio Society Strikes Again! posted by andy19191 on September 15, 2007 at 09:25:09
see if you can tell the difference between a full resolution CD and a low rez MP3. Let us know your outcome.
rw
Follow Ups:
> see if you can tell the difference between a full resolution CD and a low
> rez MP3.
First I would probably have to see some logical train of thought?
then get back with us concerning the results of your stated test.
rw
> then get back with us concerning the results of your stated test.
I think you will find that it was you that stated I perform a test. This is what I meant about the logic and train of thought thing. Bit of clarity required before the next step.
What is to stop an audiophile with a bit of confidence in those beliefs spending a few minutes making a low-res copy of a high-res CD and having a bit of a listen?
Here is your test. I have done such a comparison on good gear. How 'bout you?
rw
> I have done such a comparison on good gear.
There you go then. If you used proper controls, write it up and send it off to refute the claims in the paper.
> How 'bout you?
I am not an audiophile and have no problem with the paper. We seem to be back to this logic thing.
Evidently, your experience in such matters is absent. No surprise.
...write it up and send it off to refute the claims in the paper.
One of the lead authors, Meyer, has already done that and stated the despite the findings of the test, high rez still sounds better. No need to refute that which I agree.
rw
d
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: