|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
73.26.153.22
In Reply to: RE: I'm enjoying it on TIDAL at the moment.. posted by ahendler on July 12, 2015 at 14:08:26
Look forward to hearing about your experience with #7. I was very taken by it, except there seemed to be some flagging of the energy near the end.
Of course, that may be entirely me! Or perhaps the original version used in the recording.
Follow Ups:
Just listened to #7. I am not an expert on Bruckner symphonies but it seems to me that the last movement as performed here is really anti climatic to the rest of the symphony. It does seem to just peter out with no real climax. It could be the version. This may have been changed in Bruckners later versions. I will have to check this out. Otherwise I really think this is an excellent performance and sonics are good
Alan
So now might be a good time to remind listeners and readers about John F. Berkey's "abruckner.com" site, which, once you start poking around in it, will amaze you. Evidently a true labor of love, this site is without a doubt a thing of wonder!
As this relates to which version of the Seventh is used on Mrs. Young's recording, the site states clearly that she uses the 1885 (original version), as edited by Leopold Nowak. It used to be that about half the conductors would use the (Robert) Haas version of the Seventh, while the other half would use Nowak's. It seems to me that I've been seeing Nowak a little more recently (maybe 60/40). Both the Haas and the Nowak editions are based on the original 1885 version - the main differences are that:These differences rise to the level of moral equivalents of war for some listeners - I'm not kidding! I read one biography of Bruckner where the writer asserted that to include the bass drum, cymbal and triangle parts in the slow movement climax of the Seventh was a moral offense against Bruckner's music! (I guess the guy conveniently forgot that Bruckner DOES include bass drum and cymbal crashes - no doubt about it - at a similar spot in the slow movement of the Eighth!) ;-)
- one of them (now I forget which one!) includes tempo changes within the movements (especially noticeable in the last movement) which some people consider suspect
- at the climax of the second movement, one of them (again, I forget which one) includes parts for cymbal, bass drum and triangle, which are in the manuscript, but which are accompanied by a presumably later notation which says "gilt nicht" (not valid)
Ain't Bruckner fun? BTW, here's the link:
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: