|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
108.34.158.106
In Reply to: RE: Belshazzar's Feast posted by jec01 on October 08, 2014 at 15:18:01
One can usually count on David Hurwitz to turn music criticism into a bar fight among mixed martial arts experts... .So he here is giving a very qualified recommendation to the dark horse Naxos effort, but I think that his caveat is semi-misplaced. Yes, other issues have longer and more interesting couplings, but to take one example, the Sir Colin Davis LSO Live SACD costs 30 smackers vs. the Naxos POCD's $9.99.
Thus Spake DH:
Notes and Editorial Reviews
I wish I could give this disc the highest rating for overall artistic quality, because the performance of Belshazzar's Feast is simply spectacular, but unfortunately other equally fine performances come with more interesting couplings, and even with the two marches this release still offers less than 50 minutes of music. Make no mistake, though, if you care about the major work, then you will want to hear what Paul Daniel and his combined forces do with it. In particular, it's terrific to hear the piece sung by a really large, enthusiastic English chorus of the "festival" variety--the sort of forces that Walton composed it for in the first place. The very opening invocation ("Thus spake Isaiah") has a very different, weightier sound than usual when sung by such a crowd--greater amplitude and richness--but the words remain remarkably clear throughout.
Here's the bottom line: after the comparatively quiet and mournful first 10 minutes, Daniel basically lines up this huge mass of voices and they proceed to scream their collective guts out--and let's face it, what more would you want in this loudest and most energetic of choral works? The enthusiasm and sense of occasion is palpable, and it extends to the work of the orchestra, which renders such moments as the "Praise ye" episode with incomparable vividness from the brass and percussion. Once the piece gets hopping ("In Babylon, Belshazzar the king made a great feast") there's simply no looking back. Granted, the "Joyful noise" at the very end might pass by in a bit of a blur at this tempo, but then it nearly always does, and the Naxos recording is pretty terrific in just about every respect, capturing both an unusual amount of orchestral detail while offering the palpable impression of vast choral forces in a large space.Baritone Christopher Purves isn't the most smooth-voiced of soloists, but he gets the job done with aplomb, and the two marches (recorded way back in 1996) are effective but obviously are there for lack of anything better. Still, at budget price you won't find a snazzier Belshazzar, and for sheer "pedal to the metal" panache, this one has them all beat. If you want perfect choral discipline you may want to look elsewhere, but for a genuine musical hubbub in the best sense, look no further.
--David Hurwitz, ClassicsToday.com
Heard streaming as a higher-qual. MP3, the recorded sound is very impressive.
However, my usual default performance is a lot more fun, and take far less time to get through! Here's the Cliff's Notes version:
Tee hee.
ATB,
jm
Edits: 10/09/14Follow Ups:
Buy the LSO SACD direct from the UK. 8.99 of Her Majesty's golden quids. That's about 14 dollars. Even with shipping you are on to a winner in comparison to having to find 30 engravings of President Washington.
Sorry, I glanced at the wrong item.
Still, that's 2X what the Naxos POCD costs.
jm
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: