DVD-Audiobahn

Re: What are you debating?

195.92.168.165

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display Email ] [ DVD-Audiobahn ] [ FAQ ]

In Reply to: What are you debating? posted by Joe Murphy Jr on January 27, 2003 at 14:41:24:

I'm debating the fact that WSR always promotes DTS and gives them an open forum to wax lyrical about their latest and greatest format without ever being taken to task. DTS engineers know the limits of their formats, but I'm not so sure about their marketing people or Widescreen Review. And if you think Reber wasn't involved, wake up, he's the editor/owner/publisher.
I'm not sure who the remainder of your ramble is aimed at, there was no mention of anything other than the dubious merits of DTS 96/24 in my post, so I can only assume you're addressing someone else with the remainder.
And as for point seven, resorting to the schoolyard name-calling only serves to devalue anything sensible you may have had to say.

Follow Ups:

Noone else - Joe Murphy Jr 19:50:33 01/27/03 (0)
Your post came off, to me at least, that DTS is just a marketing game and holds no value in audio/video. That's what I was addressing with the reply. "Pissing with your pants up" is an expression -- not name-calling. I believe it does apply in regards to "my" impression of your post. Perhaps this was not your post's intent, but that's how I took it. As to the name-calling and having ones contribution "devalued", I don't believe I've met anyone whose given name was "shill" -- have you? WR is not perfect and I never said that they were. But if you think that these guys are bad, just wait until you read the "high end" mags...

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Schiit Audio

You can not post to an archived thread.