|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
206.255.205.50
In Reply to: RE: Still dodging the questions. Nice try posted by Analog Scott on December 03, 2016 at 09:01:37
You've beaten your dead horse enough already.
Perhaps you'll find someone who agrees with your position elsewhere. Best of luck to you. :)
Follow Ups:
You continue to post and yet you continue to avoid the actual subject. Why is that? (rhetorical question we both know why) Let's face it. It's not that you don't care about my questions. They are the subject of the very heart of your audio philosophy so clearly you do care about the subject. You just don't want to face the fact that they expose the nonsensical aspects of that philosophy. So feel free to keep up the hand waving and continue to avoid the subject. But just for kicks I will ask the questions again.
We are comparing the sound quality of a live piano that is overloading a room to that of a top flight concert grand piano, just tweeked by an expert technition, played by a world class pianist in a world class concert hall and heard from an excellent seat in that hall.
1. Are these "live experiences" equal in sound quality? Are they just as good as each other?
2. Is either one more or less *realistic sounding* than the other?
The idea that an audiophile who believes that live acoustic music is the reference for judging audio sound quality would not be interested in these questions is plainly absurd. You just don't like the answers. So you won't answer them.
I look forward to your next dodge. Keep on posting about something you are so disintered in. The irony of that speaks for itself. Be very careful to continue to avoid the subject.
that ongoing repetition of your point serves no useful purpose.
All three of us got it the first time around. And disagree. Maybe eventually, you'll be able to let that go. :)
So to stay on subject...
We are comparing the sound quality of a live piano that is overloading a room to that of a top flight concert grand piano, just tweeked by an expert technition, played by a world class pianist in a world class concert hall and heard from an excellent seat in that hall.
1. Are these "live experiences" equal in sound quality? Are they just as good as each other?
2. Is either one more or less *realistic sounding* than the other?
I look forward to your next post insisting that you are either not interested, that I'm a bad guy or you have already addressed these questions (you haven't) It's almost a point of curiosity what lengths you will go to to avoid answering such simple questions that speak to the foundation of the idea that live acoustic music is the reference for audio playback.
What's your next excuse?
We are comparing the sound quality of a live piano that is overloading a room to that of a top flight concert grand piano, just tweeked by an expert technition, played by a world class pianist in a world class concert hall and heard from an excellent seat in that hall.
1. Are these "live experiences" equal in sound quality? Are they just as good as each other?
2. Is either one more or less *realistic sounding* than the other?
I look forward for your next post. No doubt it will be more of the same. anything to avoid dealing with the reality these questions pose.
"For several days, he is locked in a sweat box with AS."
thank you for providing it.I also enjoy music and am very interested in the subject of sound quality.
so speaking of music and sound quality, what do you prefer? The sound quality of a live piano that is overloading a room or the sound of a top flight concert grand piano, just tweeked by an expert technition, played by a world class pianist in a world class concert hall and heard from an excellent seat in that hall?
And as this question relates to audiophilia and the belief that *any* live acoustic music is the reference for audio playback because the goal is "realism," which is more realistic? The sound quality of a live piano that is overloading a room or the sound of a top flight concert grand piano, just tweeked by an expert technition, played by a world class pianist in a world class concert hall and heard from an excellent seat in that hall? Or are they equally realistic?
Edits: 12/03/16
so speaking of music and sound quality, what do you prefer?
Clearly stated here several days ago.
I have also spoken about audio show quality here.
I'll be happy to repeat anything else I've posted if necessary.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: