Bottlehead Forum

Welcome! Need support, you got it. Or share you ideas and experiences.

Return to Bottlehead Forum

Bottlehead Forum

Re: my impression of HE2003

204.30.201.212

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display Email ] [ Bottlehead Forum ] [ FAQ ]

Skier

(A)

In Reply to: my impression of HE2003 posted by Doc B. on June 09, 2003 at 18:54:23:

I agree about the volume levels. Strangely enough, I think I was more impressed by some of the lower priced rooms, especially Rega and Creek. It seems to me that it takes more engineering skill to design a great sounding lower cost unit than to design a speaker cable that is $12,000 or an amplifier that is $80,000. Maybe I am not "sophisticated" enough, but some of the lower cost equipment sounded fantastic to my ears. It's too bad there were no DIY exhibitors.
PS-Why the high volume levels? Does it hide flaws in the system?

Follow Ups:

Reasonable insanity - Ian L 07:20:07 06/10/03 (7)
A friend of mine who runs an audio retail store believes that because turning a stereo up really high is something that is only tolerable with low distortion systems, if you have a system with low distortion you should listen to it at really high levels .
There is a sort of logic there `,;^)
- Re: Reasonable insanity - Doc B. 08:21:43 06/10/03 (6)
  Yes, I heard that exact type of pitch being made by some of the manufacturer's reps. But one could hear many forms of distortion in many systems no matter how loud or how quiet. That's just the nature of audio.
  Aside from hurting my ears, the thing that was bugging me was that some exhibitors didn't seem to be able to discern that their systems sounded more realistic at lower levels anyway.
  Certainly the same kind of thing happens at all shows, including VSAC. I guess we all key on a certain type of customer, who's taste matches ours, and set the level accordingly.
  I will generally ask a customer what level they prefer when I do an audition here at the Chateau, but at a show where you have several people in the room at once, this is not necessarily possible. Regardless, I think we all have an obligation not to damage our customer's hearing.
  Maybe I'll just wear earplugs next time...
  - Re: Reasonable insanity - Tony Glynn 12:08:46 06/10/03 (3)
    I see nothing has changed at these Shows.
    It must be remembered that these Big Shows are not about music-they are about equipment and giving audio writers something to write about until--the next Show !
    Thus the old Show rule applies. If your equipment sucks-- play it loud to disguise the fact this over priced stuff can't do the job.Dazzle 'em with fireworks etc.
    At VSAC, music seems to predominate and us 1 to 3 watt lovers tend to listen to music.
    Maybe these "Power Shows" have some merit. They can drive the music lover toward us and away from the Dark Side.
    Anyone want to bet that one of these behemouth, juggernaut ear splitting systems will make it to the "Best in Show"category???
    It all gets too Freudian. i.e. mine is bigger and louder than yours!
    On to Silverdale!!!!
    Tony
    - Re: Reasonable insanity - John Swenson 12:30:49 06/10/03 (2)
      This reminds me of my first Sterophile show (MANY years ago), most rooms were playing very loud boomy music, except for the Vandersteen room. Richard himself was playing DJ at a nice little system with his just released 2Cis, all ARC electronics and a turntable (I don't remember what it was), he played vey good music at decent levels, I kept on coming back to that room to let my ears heal before venturing out again, it was like a breath of fresh air. (guess which speakers I wound up buying)
      One dealer had this $150k system put together in a large room with lots of people packing in, it sounded all right but didn't play MUSIC, at one point they demonstrated their little "cheap" system (only $10k), THAT sounded MUCH better, it was real music.
      One dealer DID have a megabuck system that sounded really good (all ARC electronics again and Thiel CS5.0 speakers), but that was the only one, all the other places that sounded good were relatively speaking inexpensive systems.
      What I came away from that was, its much harder to make a mega-buck system sound good than a cheap system. I guess thats why I eventually wound up here in the land of "as simple as possible" audio.
      John S.
      - Bass baby - badman 19:10:12 06/10/03 (1)
        
        In Reply to: Re: Reasonable insanity posted by John Swenson on June 10, 2003 at 12:30:49:
        
        The inundation of ones skull with pounding bass at these shows gets really tiring. The rooms typically have strong bass reinforcement, and the exhibitors don't do a damn thing to naturalize the response. Not a one of my favorite rooms at HE2002 had a sub. The best (which surprisingly was actually chosen as best) I heard was the Joseph Audio room- which had bass, but was played at reasonable levels. Blue Circle was excellent- using bookshelves, again, at reasonable levels. Kimber Kable- likewise excellent, also bookshelves at reasonable levels. Triangle and Meadowlark both showed mid-size floorstanders played at reasonable levels- also good rooms. I avoided the HT demos.
        The Pipedreams sounded terrible, as did the big Dynadio- Evidences, IIRC. Not overplayed when I went in, just the systems weren't communicative.
        If and when I can afford a room, it'll have tubes and bookshelves. Just seems to be better that way at a show, as they're not so problematic in the bass, and peoples ears actually can listen to music and relax vs. the big overplayed systems.
        
        How about ProAcs ? - Ian L. 18:53:15 06/11/03 (0)
        
        In Reply to: Bass baby posted by badman on June 10, 2003 at 19:10:12:
        
        None of my gear could drive them as far as the front door but I still think they're a great speaker. So I'm curious, How are they played at the shows ?
  - Get the big ones... - Kevin P 10:18:06 06/10/03 (1)
    This is what I like to wear when mowing the lawn.
    http://www.lindensafety.com/details.cfm?id=125
    - Re: Get the big ones... - Doc B. 12:01:32 06/10/03 (0)
      As a shooter I have all sorts of hearing protection around here. 29 dB muffs are great, I have two pair. Only Howard Leight does better at 31 dB. Actually even 19 or 20dB of suppression is usually enough to do the job, short of standing next to a guy firing high power rifle. These days I use electronic muffs with mics that let anything below about 84 dB thru, and give 24dB of suppression above that level.
      But ear plugs fit the pocket a lot easier, are a lot cheaper, and good ones can offer just about as much protection as muffs. I always take a pair with me when traveling, and keep them in my pocket for when we are doing any speaker testing. Wish I had taken them to the show...but fingers are pretty good too, in a pinch.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Kimber Kable

You can not post to an archived thread.