|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
50.150.232.230
In Reply to: RE: But posted by morricab on December 16, 2014 at 15:06:23
I would also like to address your theoretical 3 db ,less say for discussion sakes you are running around 20 watts for your avg din of 84 db from listening position, a dynamic peak of 15 db will require 640 watts, clearly exceeding the 400 @3%thd clipping out of your Lamm 1.1 . Less say your super scinnies only need 10 watts to achieve 84db from your listening position, then you will still require 320 watts to reproduce the same dynamic peak , at which time the Lamm is producing above 2% thd and clipping, hence my point.
So less say you like to listen at even lower levels and size and drop your avg din to 81 db max then you will require 160 watts of power to reproduced sustained peak of 15 db , at which time your lamm would be putting out 170 watts at approx 1% thd @ 1 ohm( clipping ). Hence my point , you dislike the sound of the lamm over driven ..
Note: that anything above 100 watts is after the knee and thd is a straight line up ..SO ,
You are dynamic limited with this amplfier , IMO, it's best suited for 4 ohm and above speakers in the 88db/w/m and above range..
Regards,
Edits: 12/17/14Follow Ups:
" The M1.1's discrete clipping powers (at 1% THD+N) were 140W into 8 ohms (21.5dBW) (115V line); 138W into 4 ohms (18.4dBW) (114V line); and 230W into 2 ohms (17.6dBW) (115V line). "
The Lamm puts out 230 watts into 2 ohms at 1% and around 400 into 1 ohm.
That is in the low impedance mode.
The M1.2 was more thoroughly tested in the high impedance mode and records the following:
" Fig.4 shows how the THD+noise percentage present in the M1.2's output varies with output power with the Hi-Z bias setting into loads varying from 2 to 16 ohms. The amplifier comfortably exceeds its rated output power, giving out 180W into 8 ohms (22.6dBW), 305W into 4 ohms (21.8dBW), and 490W into 2 ohms (20.9dBW), all at 1% THD. "
So, in the high Z setting it makes nearly 500 watts into 2 ohms and half that at the low Z mode (so about the same as the M1.1) and doubles again into 1 ohm.
That is a LOT more power than you are claiming. Not 5%, not 3% but 1% THD.
"The M1.2 Reference is conservatively rated to deliver 110 Watts into 8 and 4 Ohms in pure class A operation (high and low impedance settings, respectively); 220 Watts into 2 Ohms, and 400 Watts into 1 Ohm (low impedance setting), continuous."
Since LAMMs specs were accurate at 4 and 2 ohms, I don't doubt that they are correct about their 1 ohm output (in lowZ mode). One may also safely assume that LAMM rates these at 1% THD...just like Stereophile confirms.
So, your numbers are simply out to lunch.
Speaking of lunch , I will place the test results in your lunch box , who knows .........
WHatever floats your boat A.Wayne.
BTW you never did address the fact that I reached my conclusions about the Lamms not on the Scintillas but on the Thiel CS3.7...a 90+db speaker with a minimum of 2 ohms impedance. Surely you won't tell me that the Lamms are inadequate to drive this speaker too? You look pretty silly already with your inability to read stereophile's test report on the Lamms. The fact that the same issues popped up not on one, not on two but on three different speaker systems is a fact that you have conveniently ignored in your zeal to prove me wrong about the Lamms being able to drive Scintillas just fine (a failed attempt at that).
You look silly without my input Morri, you're pretty good :) and i only addressed your high current low - z rating for the Lamm 1.1 on scinnies , thats what mostly got me started in the discussion , i guess the Thiel's are now your new strawman argument ....
Take a look at the thiels impedance phase, see anything .... ?
Regards..
Read the original post...I make it clear that I am taking them off my list because of how they sounded AFTER hearing them on Thiel CS3.7s...so much for your reading comprehension.
You do know how to entertain Morri, here's hoping you finally get to hear a good system in 2015, not good having the same bad experience every year.
So get well soon and all the best ....
Regards,
Edits: 12/20/14 12/20/14
Fortunately I get to hear a good one nearly every evening...mine.
Morri, best to focus on you Class-D shoot out , maybe toobs will be off your list next ......
Edits: 12/21/14
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: