Vinyl Asylum Welcome Licorice Pizza (LP) lovers! Setup guides and Vinyl FAQ. |
|
In Reply to: RE: Nobody wants an accurate rendering of bad sound - see my post above [nt] posted by Analog Scott on July 29, 2015 at 19:42:45:
About twelve years ago, there was a(n) (in)famous recording of the Philadelphia Orchestra under Sawallisch on the Water Lily label. (The title was "In Nature's Realm", and it contained music by Liszt and Dvorak.) This recording was made in the old Philadelphia Academy of Music, which, by then (because of all the renovations), had a shockingly bone dry acoustic. My understanding is that some of the orchestra members had such devotion to that hall that they actively lobbied the orchestra management to allow a commercial recording to be made there. They got their wish, and, moreover, they contracted with a company (Water Lily) that was famous for its minimally microphoned (and accurate!) approach to engineering. This album was also a very early instance where a 24/96 recording was actually made available to consumers - I think it even pre-dated DVD-Audio, and was available as a regular, audio-only DVD. But of course, you can imagine the result: what we hear on this recording is the accurate rendering of the hall's bone dry acoustics - very unflattering to the orchestra.
OK, so in one sense, I find this recording woefully lacking in hall reverberation. I keep thinking to myself, geez, why didn't they just record in a better hall? But, in another sense, I do RESPECT this recording, because, now, at least I have an idea as to what music in that hall really sounds like. Sure, I accept your observation that it will sound different in different seats. But, in general, I think this recording captures the quality of the hall - so I DO respect it, and I listen to it every so often (it's now on my computer) with fascination and gratitude!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- OK - I'm going to use another word in preference to "bad" - Chris from Lafayette 11:46:18 07/30/15 (6)
- RE: OK - I'm going to use another word in preference to "bad" - Analog Scott 12:54:12 07/30/15 (5)
- What I LIKE about that Sawallisch/Philadelphia recording. . . - Chris from Lafayette 15:57:51 07/30/15 (4)
- RE: What I LIKE about that Sawallisch/Philadelphia recording. . . - Analog Scott 19:19:29 07/30/15 (3)
- I hear you, but. . . - Chris from Lafayette 00:10:51 07/31/15 (2)
- RE: I hear you, but. . . - Analog Scott 05:54:47 07/31/15 (1)
- Yes I'd seen that clip before and it's fascinating - Chris from Lafayette 11:54:54 07/31/15 (0)