In Reply to: I get your point. posted by rbolaw on May 3, 2016 at 19:17:55:
A year ago I mentioned how refreshing I found Amsermet's Brahms, because of its HIP-like clarity and liveliness, and that was long before the darkness had fallen.But back then, one was allowed to venture beyond the Binary without upsetting the fanatics.
But seriously, the parallels should be obvious to anyone.
When I talk shop with fellow musicians and music lovers, I expect the context and caveats to be understood: Yes, Newey's heard that HIPsters don't use vibrato. That they play fast. That they're bass light. That they flub, etc.
**Of course** the OSR players use vibrato, of course they employ the modern standard number of string bases, (or at least newey's minimum standard, unless it's since been revised up to 10, now that he's looked at a pic of the Berliner bass section : ) and, well, Amsermet was usually pretty expedient.
It was just amusing to me that newey was singing the praises of one of the few ensembles that was unwittinglying HIP ( for reasons that you know and dont need to be told), even before the movement began.
Edits: 05/03/16
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Hugs and kisses but no: I've said in the past that the OSR sounds delightfully HIP - jdaniel@jps.net 20:08:13 05/03/16 (17)
- The 10 Basses of the Karajan BPO - And A Little Test for Jiminy - Newey 21:37:23 05/03/16 (7)
- Sigh. Was a condescending exaggeration. You're going off the deep end lately. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 21:46:46 05/03/16 (6)
- The Test Remains- Why Did Karajan Use 10 Basses??? - Newey 22:01:05 05/03/16 (5)
- For which piece? I've told you a million times it's not a fixed number, chosen by a newey- approved conductor - jdaniel@jps.net 22:32:15 05/03/16 (4)
- The Test Still Remains- Why Did Karajan Use 10 Basses?? WHY?? - Newey 22:36:26 05/03/16 (3)
- It's not a worthy question as is. It's like asking why Martha Stewart used 10 eggs. - jdaniel@jps.net 23:06:41 05/03/16 (2)
- In Other Words - YOU HAVE NO IDEA - Newey 23:12:22 05/03/16 (1)
- Do *you* know why Martha used 10 eggs? Really newey, really. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 23:19:07 05/03/16 (0)
- Jiminy's Butt-Kissing Continues - Newey 21:00:33 05/03/16 (5)
- Jiminy - You Said That Ansermet Was A Nazi - Newey 21:56:27 05/03/16 (3)
- I did? Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 22:21:13 05/03/16 (2)
- Lol I disagreed with him. Let it go. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 21:47:46 05/03/16 (0)
- And Yet Another Straw Man Shot - Will The Liar Ever Stop? - Newey 20:44:20 05/03/16 (0)
- Uh - I Was Replying To Mr. Rbolaw - Not You - Newey 20:36:25 05/03/16 (1)
- Yes I was too, about a 1/2 hour before your post. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 20:56:44 05/03/16 (0)