In Reply to: RE: The Big Fugue - Brilliant or Blunder? posted by fstein on March 26, 2015 at 13:44:26:
The Lindsay's did in fact play out of tune....their defenders claim that these audible intonation problems are actually an expressive device.....I think they just couldn't play in tune. It wasn't just Gramophone who defended them - Bernard Jacobsen was a huge fan as well. It must be like well-hung pheasant....you have to be English to appreciate it.
Fanfare reviewer Jerry Dubins is such a strong proponent of using the Gross Fugue as the final movement that he nixed a set of Beethoven quartets that he otherwise liked when they released the Gross Fugue in the set with the Middle Quartets instead of the Late Quartets.....kind of an overreaction in my mind.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: The Big Fugue - Brilliant or Blunder? - TGR 16:47:05 03/26/15 (3)
- RE: "overreaction" - TGR, you have a gift for understatement! (nt) - goldenthal 13:39:48 04/19/15 (0)
- Bernard Jacobsen, Fanfare's own "Mr. Repeat" - His ONLY claim to fame - Chris from Lafayette 17:23:40 03/26/15 (1)
- His tastes were certainly different from mine - TGR 07:50:34 03/27/15 (0)