Yes, but the Strad article was about vibrato, not about HIP in general

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Big surprise - NOT: HIPsters have vibrato all WRONG (according to The Strad) - Chris from Lafayette 00:30:28 02/22/15 (38)

There are some quartets that I always avoided - Jay Buridan 06:04:08 02/27/15 (1)

Those two groups use normal vibrato - Chris from Lafayette 12:44:01 02/27/15 (0)

NEWSFLASH: Nikolai Demidenko is a (gasp) HIPster. - Travis 16:26:58 02/23/15 (4)

RE: NEWSFLASH: Nikolai Demidenko is a (gasp) HIPster. - Chris from Lafayette 18:25:51 02/23/15 (3)

LOL! - rbolaw 09:14:55 02/24/15 (0)

Sounds a lot like the dreaded VIBRATO ENVY syndrome. - Travis 07:55:59 02/24/15 (1)

Pianists use "air vibrato". . . - Chris from Lafayette 09:38:43 02/24/15 (0)

RE: HIPsters have vibrato all WRONG ? - layman 09:54:15 02/23/15 (1)

Even with tempo, HIPsters claim credit that they don't deserve (IMHO) - Chris from Lafayette 12:52:29 02/23/15 (0)

RE: Big surprise - NOT: HIPsters have vibrato all WRONG (according to The Strad) - learsfool 22:48:14 02/22/15 (10)

The artificial lack of vibrato is instantly recognizeable in HIP performances - Chris from Lafayette 08:34:15 02/23/15 (9)

RE: The artificial lack of vibrato is instantly recognizeable in HIP performances - learsfool 21:17:07 02/23/15 (8)

Modern string players are WAY closer - Chris from Lafayette 23:50:33 02/23/15 (7)

RE: Modern string players are WAY closer - learsfool 21:14:53 02/24/15 (4)

A modern orchestra sounds fundamentally different - Chris from Lafayette 00:18:01 02/25/15 (3)

RE: A modern orchestra sounds fundamentally different - learsfool 22:59:56 02/25/15 (2)

I'm speaking in generalities with regard to strings - Chris from Lafayette 17:32:09 02/26/15 (1)

RE: I'm speaking in generalities with regard to strings - learsfool 21:08:01 02/26/15 (0)

RE: Modern string players are WAY closer - Travis 07:52:52 02/24/15 (1)

Poor demented souls! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 09:34:06 02/24/15 (0)

From a distance - Amphissa 13:43:12 02/22/15 (1)

RE: From a distance - jec01 07:40:15 02/23/15 (0)

Excellent response by Mark Bailey in the comment section - rbolaw 08:56:56 02/22/15 (6)

Yup--Leopold Auer. For some reason... - C.B. 12:25:45 02/22/15 (5)

Auer's extracted quote in Bailey's self-serving reply. . . - Chris from Lafayette 15:38:52 02/22/15 (4)

Ahh, Chris ... - rbolaw 16:10:52 02/22/15 (3)

Yes, but the Strad article was about vibrato, not about HIP in general - Chris from Lafayette 21:04:11 02/22/15 (2)

RE: Yes, but the Strad article was about vibrato, not about HIP in general - goldenthal 17:04:59 02/24/15 (1)

Hey - I do what I can when I'm fighting the good fight [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 19:00:43 02/24/15 (0)

You obviously didn't read the article--it talks about *light* vibrato... - C.B. 08:54:50 02/22/15 (8)

Believe me, I read the article - but I wonder if you did - Chris from Lafayette 14:59:42 02/22/15 (5)

RE: Believe me, I read the article - but I wonder if you did - rbolaw 20:29:43 02/22/15 (2)

Yes - but if I transport myself to that time. . . - Chris from Lafayette 21:25:30 02/22/15 (1)

Pretty. But not quiet. ;) nt - rbolaw 05:25:11 02/23/15 (0)

It's all relative... - C.B. 19:20:57 02/22/15 (1)

Thanks for your thoughtful reply - Chris from Lafayette 20:46:54 02/22/15 (0)

RE: Thanks, also. - Travis 14:25:16 02/22/15 (0)

Thanks - rbolaw 09:51:18 02/22/15 (0)

Follow Ups

Yes, but the Strad article was about vibrato, not about HIP in general - Chris from Lafayette 21:04:11 02/22/15 (2)

RE: Yes, but the Strad article was about vibrato, not about HIP in general - goldenthal 17:04:59 02/24/15 (1)

Hey - I do what I can when I'm fighting the good fight [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 19:00:43 02/24/15 (0)

Post a Message!