RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release?

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - Chris from Lafayette 11:00:46 08/26/14 (61)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - rbolaw 16:12:17 08/26/14 (55)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - Chris from Lafayette 18:21:04 08/26/14 (47)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - srl1 08:51:34 08/27/14 (1)

Yeah - I think we agree pretty much about everything except ASO! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 10:19:37 08/27/14 (0)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - rbolaw 20:07:45 08/26/14 (44)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - Chris from Lafayette 00:36:30 08/27/14 (43)

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - Analog Scott 03:53:28 08/27/14 (42)

"Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - tinear 08:55:44 08/27/14 (37)

RE: "Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - Analog Scott 08:20:08 08/28/14 (3)

Right, musicianship has improved since Mozart, Beethoven, and - tinear 21:11:01 08/28/14 (2)

I'll let Scott argue his own points, however. . . - Chris from Lafayette 21:30:12 08/28/14 (0)

RE: Right, musicianship has improved since Mozart, Beethoven, and - Analog Scott 21:29:13 08/28/14 (0)

RE: "Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - Chris from Lafayette 11:31:54 08/27/14 (32)

Well, we differ. It is more enjoyable to hear a perfectly recorded symphony, of course, but - tinear 21:30:22 08/28/14 (25)

RE: Well, we differ. It is more enjoyable to hear a perfectly recorded symphony, of course, but - Chris from Lafayette 22:22:25 08/28/14 (18)

I didn't say Bach invented those musical forms, I said he (his music) was - tinear 08:50:01 08/29/14 (17)

So. . . have you found anyone else who agrees with your notion of Bach's "originality"? - Chris from Lafayette 10:38:19 08/29/14 (13)

So you're saying that composing something with great mastery and that demands unprecedented technique - tinear 11:08:03 08/29/14 (12)

RE: So you're saying that composing something with great mastery and that demands unprecedented technique - Analog Scott 11:30:35 08/29/14 (2)

If you reread the context, you'll note two different points about those named individuals. - tinear 11:46:07 08/29/14 (1)

You still didn't answer the question - Analog Scott 11:56:44 08/29/14 (0)

tin, I feel sympathy for you - Chris from Lafayette 11:28:05 08/29/14 (8)

"[T]o each his own!" - rbolaw 15:53:23 08/29/14 (5)

Believe me, no condescension intended about FM Radio listening - Chris from Lafayette 17:54:11 08/29/14 (2)

RE: Believe me, no condescension intended about FM Radio listening - Analog Scott 18:03:51 08/29/14 (1)

Yes, Moravec is remarkable - rbolaw 18:25:30 08/29/14 (0)

RE: "[T]o each his own!" - Analog Scott 17:38:42 08/29/14 (0)

Thank you. nt - David Smith 16:57:25 08/29/14 (0)

I like sympathy, no matter how misplaced. I enjoy listening to - tinear 11:47:41 08/29/14 (1)

RE: I like sympathy, no matter how misplaced. I enjoy listening to - Analog Scott 11:58:25 08/29/14 (0)

RE: I didn't say Bach invented those musical forms, I said he (his music) was - Analog Scott 09:16:45 08/29/14 (2)

Nope. nt - tinear 11:48:57 08/29/14 (1)

Yup. nt - Analog Scott 11:59:17 08/29/14 (0)

Please explain... - Analog Scott 22:00:55 08/28/14 (5)

I wasn't speaking of methodologies, specifically. I was speaking of - tinear 08:58:41 08/29/14 (4)

RE: I wasn't speaking of methodologies, specifically. I was speaking of - Analog Scott 09:28:51 08/29/14 (3)

You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - tinear 11:55:43 08/29/14 (2)

RE: You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - Analog Scott 12:25:21 08/29/14 (0)

RE: You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - Chris from Lafayette 12:13:40 08/29/14 (0)

Here I completely agree with you. - rbolaw 12:55:10 08/27/14 (5)

RE: Here I completely agree with you. - welltempered1 06:51:13 08/28/14 (3)

BTW, I see that this is only your 10th Post - Chris from Lafayette 15:14:15 08/29/14 (0)

Scott and Chris would correct you. - tinear 11:57:32 08/29/14 (1)

Please don't speak for me - Analog Scott 12:49:34 08/29/14 (0)

Yeah - I miss Brian - Chris from Lafayette 17:03:42 08/27/14 (0)

I think one needs to pick and choose - rbolaw 06:52:42 08/27/14 (3)

RE: I think one needs to pick and choose - Analog Scott 21:46:58 08/27/14 (0)

Finally listened to Lise's new Schumann disc on Spotify - meh! - Chris from Lafayette 12:21:58 08/27/14 (1)

Wow! What an annoying mannerism / affectation. - rbolaw 09:24:24 08/29/14 (0)

Ha... - kuma 16:55:02 08/26/14 (6)

I posted about ASO a couple of years ago - Chris from Lafayette 18:05:31 08/26/14 (5)

I hate to say this.... - Penguin 18:42:51 08/28/14 (1)

LOL! Maybe so! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 19:18:19 08/28/14 (0)

well, I'd assume that anyone who gets a booking at major convert halls... - kuma 18:28:45 08/26/14 (2)

Maybe you'd have better luck with Valentina Toth - andy evans 03:36:43 08/27/14 (1)

Excellent Disc nt - srl1 08:32:33 08/27/14 (0)

Who cares? [nt] - Amphissa 15:14:34 08/26/14 (4)

you cannot judge a cd by its cover (nt) - Penguin 18:38:56 08/28/14 (0)

The evidence speaks for itself [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 18:10:44 08/26/14 (2)

A picture is worth 1,000,000 notes [nt] - Amphissa 20:38:42 08/26/14 (1)

RE: A picture is worth 1,000,000 notes [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 11:47:09 08/31/14 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: Things soundin' bad in babe pianist's latest release? - Analog Scott 03:53:28 08/27/14 (42)

"Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - tinear 08:55:44 08/27/14 (37)

RE: "Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - Analog Scott 08:20:08 08/28/14 (3)

Right, musicianship has improved since Mozart, Beethoven, and - tinear 21:11:01 08/28/14 (2)

I'll let Scott argue his own points, however. . . - Chris from Lafayette 21:30:12 08/28/14 (0)

RE: Right, musicianship has improved since Mozart, Beethoven, and - Analog Scott 21:29:13 08/28/14 (0)

RE: "Overrated:" by whom? By the listeners that flocked for decades to their concerts? By their peers that praised - Chris from Lafayette 11:31:54 08/27/14 (32)

Well, we differ. It is more enjoyable to hear a perfectly recorded symphony, of course, but - tinear 21:30:22 08/28/14 (25)

RE: Well, we differ. It is more enjoyable to hear a perfectly recorded symphony, of course, but - Chris from Lafayette 22:22:25 08/28/14 (18)

I didn't say Bach invented those musical forms, I said he (his music) was - tinear 08:50:01 08/29/14 (17)

So. . . have you found anyone else who agrees with your notion of Bach's "originality"? - Chris from Lafayette 10:38:19 08/29/14 (13)

So you're saying that composing something with great mastery and that demands unprecedented technique - tinear 11:08:03 08/29/14 (12)

RE: So you're saying that composing something with great mastery and that demands unprecedented technique - Analog Scott 11:30:35 08/29/14 (2)

If you reread the context, you'll note two different points about those named individuals. - tinear 11:46:07 08/29/14 (1)

You still didn't answer the question - Analog Scott 11:56:44 08/29/14 (0)

tin, I feel sympathy for you - Chris from Lafayette 11:28:05 08/29/14 (8)

"[T]o each his own!" - rbolaw 15:53:23 08/29/14 (5)

Believe me, no condescension intended about FM Radio listening - Chris from Lafayette 17:54:11 08/29/14 (2)

RE: Believe me, no condescension intended about FM Radio listening - Analog Scott 18:03:51 08/29/14 (1)

Yes, Moravec is remarkable - rbolaw 18:25:30 08/29/14 (0)

RE: "[T]o each his own!" - Analog Scott 17:38:42 08/29/14 (0)

Thank you. nt - David Smith 16:57:25 08/29/14 (0)

I like sympathy, no matter how misplaced. I enjoy listening to - tinear 11:47:41 08/29/14 (1)

RE: I like sympathy, no matter how misplaced. I enjoy listening to - Analog Scott 11:58:25 08/29/14 (0)

RE: I didn't say Bach invented those musical forms, I said he (his music) was - Analog Scott 09:16:45 08/29/14 (2)

Nope. nt - tinear 11:48:57 08/29/14 (1)

Yup. nt - Analog Scott 11:59:17 08/29/14 (0)

Please explain... - Analog Scott 22:00:55 08/28/14 (5)

I wasn't speaking of methodologies, specifically. I was speaking of - tinear 08:58:41 08/29/14 (4)

RE: I wasn't speaking of methodologies, specifically. I was speaking of - Analog Scott 09:28:51 08/29/14 (3)

You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - tinear 11:55:43 08/29/14 (2)

RE: You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - Analog Scott 12:25:21 08/29/14 (0)

RE: You have a way of taking argument to extremes. - Chris from Lafayette 12:13:40 08/29/14 (0)

Here I completely agree with you. - rbolaw 12:55:10 08/27/14 (5)

RE: Here I completely agree with you. - welltempered1 06:51:13 08/28/14 (3)

BTW, I see that this is only your 10th Post - Chris from Lafayette 15:14:15 08/29/14 (0)

Scott and Chris would correct you. - tinear 11:57:32 08/29/14 (1)

Please don't speak for me - Analog Scott 12:49:34 08/29/14 (0)

Yeah - I miss Brian - Chris from Lafayette 17:03:42 08/27/14 (0)

I think one needs to pick and choose - rbolaw 06:52:42 08/27/14 (3)

RE: I think one needs to pick and choose - Analog Scott 21:46:58 08/27/14 (0)

Finally listened to Lise's new Schumann disc on Spotify - meh! - Chris from Lafayette 12:21:58 08/27/14 (1)

Wow! What an annoying mannerism / affectation. - rbolaw 09:24:24 08/29/14 (0)

Post a Message!