In Reply to: I was going to write that although Kuijken's set is well (IE simply) recorded posted by Timbo in Oz on August 16, 2014 at 16:44:02:
with a certain Severius.
I feel strongly that being able to read a score and recognise *some* of what the composer put into the music is crucial to understanding the importance and magnitude of the piece.
But many music listeners, including a few on this forum, feel that analysis lessens one's immediate enjoyment. You know, the immediate satisfaction that comes with a visceral, non-thinking sort of response. "It's got a beat and I can dance to it". (Typical pop-music sort of mindset).
When I was a teenager (about a half-century ago), I had an argument with my next-door neighbour, who had a big stereo system and loved the 'big gesture' of Beethoven. He thought Mozart and Bach were 'trite'. I didn't have the ammo then to demolish him and his cretinism, although I know now exactly what I'd say if I saw him again.
With the advent of hip-hop and the desecration of music education in the schools (at least in the U.S.), the sort of musical understanding that comes with analysis and historical awareness is receding even further in the rear-view mirror. Most people in my area who go to symphony concerts do so for social (business expense?) reasons, not for edification.
-
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- We've had that discussion before on thi sforum... - C.B. 18:19:42 08/16/14 (6)
- This is a classic reductivist mind set mistake. - Timbo in Oz 19:30:33 08/16/14 (5)
- What you are describing is the male point of view. - genungo 20:17:16 08/16/14 (4)
- Nope, it's a deeply held idea that constantly and negatively effects micro-decisions and macro-decisions - Timbo in Oz 20:36:03 08/16/14 (3)
- RE: Nope, it's a deeply held idea that constantly and negatively effects micro-decisions and macro-decisions - genungo 20:37:16 08/16/14 (2)
- I think a concept just bounced off the wall behind you. - Timbo in Oz 20:40:21 08/16/14 (1)
- RE: I think a concept just bounced off the wall behind you. - genungo 20:59:50 08/16/14 (0)