In Reply to: RE: I Bought That Box Set A While Back........ posted by rbolaw on April 10, 2014 at 08:56:29:
And now Analogue Productions is in the process of reissuing some of the same titles that Soundmirror issued in the original RCA SACD series from a few years ago. One big difference is that these new reissues are LESS generously filled (i.e., keeping exactly the same contents as on the original LP's). For instance, the Reiner/Chicago album of Respighi's Pines and Fountains contains only those works (just as on the LP), while the earlier Soundmirror SACD also included Debussy's La Mer.
And yet. . . although I have the earlier SACD's and XRCD's of many of these albums. . . I just couldn't help myself and gave in to the temptation of getting a couple of the new Analogue Productions SACD's: Reiner's Pines and Fountains as well as his Sheherazade. I then compared my copies of the AP SACD's, the SM SACD's, and (in the case of the Respighi) the JVC XRCD.
Maybe my assessment is influenced by our human psychology of thinking that when we pay more for something, it must be better. (Let's not even go near audio equipment here!). Nevertheless, it seems to me that the new AP SACD incarnations of these performances are the best yet in terms of timbre, separation, and sense of space (more of my comments on SA-CD.net - link below). I may be stupid, but I think I may be buying more of these AP SACD reissues as they come out. And BTW, they are planning some titles (such as the Szeryng Symphonie espagnole) which were not in the earlier SACD series. So FWIW. . .
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- And still they come. . . new SACD Living Stereo re-issues @ $30 a pop - Chris from Lafayette 11:30:25 04/10/14 (7)
- Completely agree with your conclusions... - Russell 18:23:36 04/10/14 (2)
- RE: Completely agree with your conclusions... - Chris from Lafayette 15:10:09 04/11/14 (1)
- Yes, I have (got the download). It's pretty over the top, but I like it! (nt) - Russell 13:18:13 04/12/14 (0)
- That's good news - rbolaw 12:18:33 04/10/14 (3)
- I admit - it's a neurosis! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 12:26:14 04/10/14 (2)
- So what you seem to be saying... - Ivan303 06:58:27 04/11/14 (1)
- Indeed! The adventure can be yours too! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 08:27:09 04/11/14 (0)