In Reply to: Blind-tested soloists unable to tell Stradivarius violins from modern instruments posted by newdreams on April 7, 2014 at 10:43:24:
back in February with this post and there's a different side to the *unable to tell* claim.
What Really Happened...
"I was not asked to identify specifically which was the modern violin and which was the old violin; only which I preferred. If people are concluding from this study that "professional violinists can't tell the difference between modern violinist and old Italians," then I think we need a different study in which violinists are actually asked to identify that. "
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- We've talked about this before - E-Stat 12:59:40 04/07/14 (16)
- RE: We've talked about this before - Pat D 17:41:17 04/08/14 (0)
- Sounds like a cop-out to me - Feanor 20:23:23 04/07/14 (1)
- Would you pay - E-Stat 05:41:10 04/08/14 (0)
- Thanks for posting this... - mkuller 15:00:17 04/07/14 (12)
- Well, at some point, why don't DBT tests have results doubters expect? - tinear 20:52:01 04/07/14 (5)
- RE: Well, at some point, why don't DBT tests have results doubters expect? - DrChaos 22:52:56 04/07/14 (0)
- RE: Well, at some point, why don't DBT tests have results doubters expect? - middleground 22:50:51 04/07/14 (0)
- RE: Well, at some point, why don't DBT tests have results doubters expect? - mkuller 21:58:37 04/07/14 (2)
- Well, that's convincing. Let's all just anoint you as the ARBITER OF SCIENTIFIC TESTING. - tinear 08:00:34 04/08/14 (1)
- Blinded by SCIENCE... - mkuller 10:10:02 04/08/14 (0)
- It's always about the details... - E-Stat 15:15:36 04/07/14 (5)
- Yes, that was the definitive paragraph - rickmcinnis@dogwoodfabrics.com 06:55:22 04/08/14 (1)
- Well worded - E-Stat 07:10:29 04/08/14 (0)
- Too funny yet... - mkuller 15:17:15 04/07/14 (2)
- Even out of tune... - Ozzie 17:45:13 04/07/14 (1)
- The test was... - mkuller 20:31:41 04/07/14 (0)