Home General Asylum

General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories.

The end of CD as a recording media vs the end of RedBook as a recording standard?

Is Red Book dead (As a recording format/standard)? Not quite yet. It looks much healthier that both SACD and DVD-A. Is CD dead as a recording media? What are the alternatives? I wouldn't mind to keep my music on a very large hard drive, but then I have to make sure it won't crash (so I need some kind of RAID), and also I need something I can play the recordings at different locations, in and our the house, so I need some extra electronics as well.

So: for the time being I've decided to stay with CD as a media, because (a) it does not crash as a hard drive, (b) I can play it on variety of devices, most do not depend on having some software runing. So I consider CD convenient kind of media. The future development may create some other, more convenient alternatives. As it stands now I have roughly 2,000 CDs, may be more. I have a few CD players, including portable ones, so I can't have all my collection on iPod or even on a large hard drive, again, I would need RAID, and I just don't want to get involved. Digital download? You need some extra time on your hands.


This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
  Sonic Craft  


Follow Ups Full Thread
Follow Ups
  • The end of CD as a recording media vs the end of RedBook as a recording standard? - porky_pig_jr 15:27:38 02/11/07 (0)


You can not post to an archived thread.