After dozens of blind A/B tests, it is clear that AL and AIFFs differ slightly in playback. The AL file almost always sounds better. Is iTunes/QT decoding AL files and massaging gain and EQ? I can deal with that and wait for better decoders/players as long as the quality of the audio data is identical to AIFF or WAV, and we know (?) that it is (see below). I would love to save big $$$ on disk space, but I will NEVER rip from CD again.Tests: WAV->AL->WAV tests (wav file encoded with Apple Lossless then converted back to wav) demonstrate that the two files are identical (I used a simple UNIX diff command to confirm others' results using more sophisticate tools).
Any thoughts?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 08:46:23 05/14/04 (34)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Gordon Rankin 13:02:28 05/17/04 (19)
- Re: newbie help AL vs. AIFF - head_unit 09:57:06 05/19/04 (10)
- Re: newbie help AL vs. AIFF - Stephen 15:48:14 05/19/04 (4)
- Compression ratio and classical music - Jsterritt 08:56:22 05/21/04 (1)
- Tagging classical music - Stephen 16:20:21 05/21/04 (0)
- Duh, guess I gotta open my eyes - head_unit 17:03:44 05/19/04 (1)
- Re: Duh, guess I gotta open my eyes - Stephen 17:16:05 05/19/04 (0)
- Re: newbie help AL vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 12:51:48 05/19/04 (4)
- Such as what exactly? - head_unit 14:29:13 05/19/04 (3)
- Apple Lossless Conjecture - Jsterritt 15:17:31 05/19/04 (2)
- iPod update, Apple Lossless info, AIFF-)AL Converting help. - Gordon Rankin 13:22:29 05/20/04 (0)
- Yes, it's "perfect sound forever" :-D - head_unit 17:08:01 05/19/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 16:46:49 05/17/04 (7)
- Some insight - Gordon Rankin 12:39:42 05/18/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - pburke 10:44:57 05/18/04 (5)
- Peter some thought - Gordon Rankin 12:45:45 05/18/04 (4)
- Re: Peter some thought - pburke 18:03:41 05/19/04 (3)
- A $4600 G3 laptop - Jsterritt 09:36:40 05/21/04 (0)
- Peter who said we where listening to the PC/MACs audio output? - Gordon Rankin 09:23:15 05/20/04 (1)
- Re: Peter who said we where listening to the PC/MACs audio output? - pburke 14:44:35 05/20/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Tuckers 22:39:18 05/14/04 (7)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 00:48:13 05/15/04 (6)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Tuckers 02:57:19 05/15/04 (4)
- Tuckers, would you care... - jusbe 13:48:06 05/15/04 (3)
- Re: Tuckers, would you care... - Tuckers 02:18:59 05/16/04 (2)
- Thanks T. Incidentally, - jusbe 06:00:11 05/16/04 (1)
- Re: Thanks T. Incidentally, - Tuckers 23:03:54 05/16/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Stephen 02:27:27 05/15/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - James L 20:54:20 05/14/04 (1)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 23:53:14 05/14/04 (0)
- Solid state memory - jusbe 16:09:47 05/14/04 (0)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Budrew 09:05:32 05/14/04 (2)
- Re: Apple Lossless vs. AIFF - Jsterritt 09:57:03 05/14/04 (1)
- Gotcha, thanks. nt - Budrew 14:10:32 05/14/04 (0)