RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS"

Posted by Tony Lauck (A) on March 14, 2012 at 20:40:31

In Reply to: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" posted by tom.dennehy on March 14, 2012 at 04:57:59:

"Hypothesis #2. To get an objective measure of correlation, I mixed aligned versions of all WAV/AAC pairs (one in-phase, the other phase-inverted) and calculated the RMS volume of the resulting difference wave. That is, on average, how audible the difference is between the WAV file and AAC file tested. Results below."

The use of RMS differeneces to evaluate errors produced by complex encoders that are based on psycho-acoustic principles is invalid. This is akin to comparing distortion in amplifiers by a single "THD" number.

There are two main suggestions in Apple's recommendation: keep levels safely below maximum and use 24 bit input to the encoder. Both of these have been known for some time, at least by those engineers who would rather try and avoid having anything to do with AAC or MP3. The errors caused by overloaded encoders and decoders can be gross. The differences gained by encoding with 24 bit audio are subtle, more akin to the differences between 24 bit and 16 bit uncompressed PCM at 44 kHz. Even if both suggestions are followed the results will still be rotten, it's just a question of the degree of stench. If Apple were really interested in sound quality they would be offering lossless downloads in the iTunes store.

Tony Lauck

"Diversity is the law of nature; no two entities in this universe are uniform." - P.R. Sarkar

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 04:57:59 03/14/12 (11)

Just avoid compression, simple. - Tromatic 16:44:21 03/15/12 (0)

"Sounded More like the CD"........... - Todd Krieger 00:13:09 03/15/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 20:40:31 03/14/12 (8)

Turns Out, Mastered for iTunes May Be Nothing New - tom.dennehy 06:31:22 03/20/12 (1)

RE: Turns Out, Mastered for iTunes May Be Nothing New - Tony Lauck 07:11:32 03/20/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 08:54:16 03/15/12 (5)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 11:23:50 03/15/12 (4)

Good to see the (correct) Korzybski affirmation. NT - Poles Apart 18:31:40 03/18/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 11:34:03 03/15/12 (2)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 11:54:46 03/15/12 (1)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 17:28:47 03/15/12 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 20:40:31 03/14/12 (8)

Turns Out, Mastered for iTunes May Be Nothing New - tom.dennehy 06:31:22 03/20/12 (1)

RE: Turns Out, Mastered for iTunes May Be Nothing New - Tony Lauck 07:11:32 03/20/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 08:54:16 03/15/12 (5)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 11:23:50 03/15/12 (4)

Good to see the (correct) Korzybski affirmation. NT - Poles Apart 18:31:40 03/18/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 11:34:03 03/15/12 (2)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - Tony Lauck 11:54:46 03/15/12 (1)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS" - tom.dennehy 17:28:47 03/15/12 (0)

RE: Mastered for iTunes Critic Used Flawed Test to "Say BS"

Post a Message!