|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: Why audio reviews are meaningless, though maybe fun to read posted by abajaj11 on May 19, 2004 at 07:21:44:
A good reviewer will work hard to get the most performance out of a loudspeaker, using a number of different amps and moving them around the room for best placement. When I was reviewing, I would try to hear a loudspeaker in at least two different rooms (sometimes the local dealer would be the second) and with a least three different amps (one tubed). If the reviewer is doing his job, the review should reflect pretty accurately the sonic signature of the speaker - what you will hear under similar circumstances. Entertainment value is important but not as important as care and accuracy IMO.Even having said all that anyone who purchases a product based on a review, without auditioning the product at length, and preferably in their own system and room - well, is foolish. Reviews should be used as guides to add or eliminate products to your list to audition.
Regards,
Mike
Follow Ups:
nt
I ask myself that from time to time when I miss it. After 15 years of reviewing I decided I was finally tired of listening to different equipment constantly and just wanted to enjoy the music for a change. At the time, 4 years ago, I was starting a new business, my daughters were beginning to become teenagers and I decided my energy was better spent focusing on other things than trying to meet publishing deadlines. TAS was taking off in a different direction under new ownership and no longer had the "small family" feel of the past. It seemed like a good time to exit.
Regards,
Mike
...it's trying to lift the 100 plus lb amps with no handles and razorblade heatsinks that can be a challenge. And I've been known to utter a cuss word or two wrestling with power cords that weigh more than the components themselves. Other than that, things have been going fairly well so far. Although HP is the one who originally hired me, Robert Harley's a good guy and I enjoy writing for him as well.
just try to keep out of the way of the inter-magazine politics. If I can help in any way, just let me know.
Regards,
Mike
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: