Poor baby

Poor baby

Posted by unclestu (D) on February 16, 2013 at 13:13:17

In Reply to: So what? posted by geoffkait on February 16, 2013 at 03:44:33:

Sheldrake refutes the experiment you claim is proof of his theory. Note I never said his theory was incorrect, but there is sufficient writings to show that David Bohm, the noted physicist, never fully endorsed Sheldrake, no matter how much you want to claim that it is so.

As such, despite your addled reasoning:

1. There is NO proof of Morphic resonance, and as a matter of fact Sheldrake himself says any such proof may not be possible.

2. To quote Bohm's name as actively supporting morphic resonance, does NOT match the information contained in Bohm's body of work.

3. Some of the examples in Sheldrake's book run contrary to, say, the work of Francis Crick. Certainly the molecular formation of the crystals mentioned falls actually in support of current thoughts of quantum theory, and has no relation to morphic resonance, since the electron quanta is what really determines the molecular formation, and which is also very predictable. If you are saying that quantum theory is a manifestation of morphic resonance, then so be it, but then with the quantum theory many things are explainabe, aren't they?

4. You desire validation so much you take an experiment put forth by Sheldrake and when later refuted by the man, you still claim that it is "proof" of his theory? Please reread your backfire effect article on wikipedia, as that seems to be your primary source of information. If that is not the backfire effect in operation, I don't know what would serve as a better example.

As for the precise quotes and such , I don't bother to memorize data which has no further use. That info was given in a previous thread on Morphic resonance on this very forum, BTw, and you were an integral part of tht particular discussion. However, it is a tribute to your reading comprehension that you retain no memory of that thread. IIR , and if you care to look it up, it was contained in a web based book on Sheldrake's website. But then why bother, if you didn't accept the refutaion back then why should you change your mind ?

BACKFIRE EFFECT.......

hahahahahaha

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Biofeedback or Muscle Testing to measure tweaks - Nirmala 19:09:38 02/12/13 (34)

RE: Biofeedback or Muscle Testing to measure tweaks - Tony Lauck 16:57:32 02/13/13 (27)

RE: Biofeedback or Muscle Testing to measure tweaks - geoffkait 08:08:39 02/14/13 (26)

RE: Biofeedback or Muscle Testing to measure tweaks - Tony Lauck 09:31:03 02/14/13 (25)

Definitely felt muscle relaxation listen to cj - ph5y 15:18:30 05/27/13 (2)

RE: Definitely felt muscle relaxation listen to cj - May Belt 08:51:22 05/28/13 (1)

"...that very reaction could affect brain state in ways that are not necessarily conscious." - Kal Rubinson 12:58:11 11/11/13 (0)

RE: Biofeedback or Muscle Testing to measure tweaks - geoffkait 10:39:02 02/14/13 (21)

Absolutely Hilarious - unclestu 14:14:10 02/14/13 (20)

Color yourself confused - geoffkait 14:39:21 02/14/13 (19)

Lack of logic here, BIG time - unclestu 14:59:07 02/14/13 (18)

If you want to impress me... - geoffkait 15:31:52 02/14/13 (17)

Poor baby....... - unclestu 16:01:36 02/14/13 (16)

Uh, Stu - geoffkait 16:27:34 02/14/13 (15)

Your reading comprehension simply sucks. - unclestu 18:41:17 02/14/13 (14)

RE: Your reading comprehension simply sucks. - Tony Lauck 09:01:17 02/16/13 (1)

Actually, I agree - geoffkait 09:53:19 02/16/13 (0)

Ironic, isn't it? - geoffkait 22:43:15 02/14/13 (11)

Reading comprehension failure again - unclestu 11:43:58 02/15/13 (10)

I'm very impressed - geoffkait 12:50:30 02/15/13 (9)

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA - unclestu 15:18:44 02/15/13 (8)

That's pretty silly - geoffkait 16:13:40 02/15/13 (7)

Lets see.... - unclestu 17:58:23 02/15/13 (6)

So what? - geoffkait 03:44:33 02/16/13 (5)

Poor baby - unclestu 13:13:17 02/16/13 (4)

This is your mind on drugs - geoffkait 15:00:52 02/16/13 (3)

Duhhhh..... - unclestu 15:54:53 02/16/13 (2)

Theory and Practice - Tony Lauck 08:48:42 02/17/13 (1)

I believe we are - unclestu 12:24:44 02/17/13 (0)

RE: Biofeedback - unclestu 22:00:26 02/12/13 (5)

RE: Biofeedback - Nirmala 07:08:09 02/13/13 (4)

Except for the cost - unclestu 11:44:23 02/13/13 (3)

RE: Except for the cost - Nirmala 12:44:23 02/13/13 (0)

RE: Except for the cost - Nirmala 12:40:16 02/13/13 (1)

Ahhhh.... - unclestu 13:09:49 02/13/13 (0)

Follow Ups

Poor baby - unclestu 13:13:17 02/16/13 (4)

This is your mind on drugs - geoffkait 15:00:52 02/16/13 (3)

Duhhhh..... - unclestu 15:54:53 02/16/13 (2)

Theory and Practice - Tony Lauck 08:48:42 02/17/13 (1)

I believe we are - unclestu 12:24:44 02/17/13 (0)

Post a Message!