If products standards have gone up in 20yrs, maybe reviewer standards need to go up too! (nt)

Critic's Corner

Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry.

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - TAS Editor's comments defending the review process - uw312@aol.com 13:08:44 05/22/04 (30)

Re: TAS Editor's comments defending the review process - hexenboden 18:40:07 05/23/04 (2)

Re: TAS Editor's comments defending the review process - Sean 01:02:15 05/25/04 (1)

Harley's sentence... - LarryB 07:35:37 05/25/04 (0)

I don't get your rant. - bwkendall 11:26:12 05/23/04 (2)

No, you certainly don't! - uw312@aol.com 14:16:45 05/23/04 (1)

Just a couple of comments..... - bwkendall 14:48:59 05/23/04 (0)

Re: Well then, how about this arguement. for favorable reviews... - mkuller 14:44:23 05/22/04 (8)

Re: Well then, how about this arguement. for favorable reviews... - TomLarson 18:06:48 05/26/04 (0)

For the most part, I agree... - uw312@aol.com 14:54:22 05/22/04 (2)

Re: The reviewer's job.... - mkuller 10:48:23 05/26/04 (0)

Re: For the most part, I agree... - elmuncy@yahoo.com 15:55:33 05/22/04 (0)

Re: Well then, how about this arguement. for favorable reviews... - Fisherdude 17:10:51 05/22/04 (0)

If products standards have gone up in 20yrs, maybe reviewer standards need to go up too! (nt) - Steve Cortez 19:39:15 05/22/04 (0)

Re: Well then, how about this arguement. for favorable reviews... - jrb15 20:17:55 05/22/04 (1)

Re: I always thought it was the reviewer's job to compare... - mkuller 11:39:12 05/24/04 (0)

Re: TAS Editor's comments defending the review process - Sean 15:32:40 05/22/04 (10)

Re: TAS Editor's comments defending the review process - uw312@aol.com 09:51:25 05/23/04 (0)

well said sean. - nigelbetts 00:58:29 05/23/04 (8)

Then you and Sean must be test-tube people. - bwkendall 16:19:30 05/23/04 (2)

Re: Then you and Sean must be test-tube people. - nigelbetts 18:03:36 05/23/04 (1)

I don't know Sam and have never read his stuff. - bwkendall 16:00:46 05/24/04 (0)

Can I say something? - Sue Kraft 06:18:55 05/23/04 (4)

Re: So Sue, have you blasted any of the products you've reviewed? (nt) - mkuller 11:57:08 05/23/04 (2)

no - Sue Kraft 12:46:49 05/23/04 (1)

Sue, some people don't 'get' that a bad component... - mcbrion@aol.com 11:18:58 06/01/04 (0)

Re: Can I say something? - nigelbetts 09:15:10 05/23/04 (0)

Something I would like to see. . . - unrulyjulie 22:20:00 05/22/04 (3)

What nonsense...a review doesn't take months?! - mcbrion@aol.com 11:10:52 06/01/04 (1)

Typo correction on the last five lines of my post... - mcbrion@aol.com 10:40:45 06/02/04 (0)

Re: Something I would like to see. . . - mkuller 12:14:15 05/23/04 (0)

Follow Ups

If products standards have gone up in 20yrs, maybe reviewer standards need to go up too! (nt) - Steve Cortez 19:39:15 05/22/04 (0)

165.21.154.16