Music Lane

It's all about the music, dude! Sit down, relax and listen to some tunes.

Return to Music Lane


Message Sort: Post Order or Asylum Reverse Threaded

Tchaikovsky Competition Round I (Piano): Predictions

73.222.105.47

Posted on June 20, 2015 at 11:48:09
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012
OK, I haven't heard all the competitors in the piano division (probably only about 28 of the 36), but that's not going to stop me from predicting who gets in to the second round. Twelve of the 36 competitors in the first round will make it into the second round, and we've got about an hour or two before they're announced. So here are my fearless forecasts (six of them anyway):

There are two pianists that I've heard who seem to be head and shoulders above the rest:

Lukas Geniusas (Russia/Lithuania) - He placed second in the most recent Chopin Competition and the level of finish in his playing is incredible, not to mention the whirlwind tempo he took in the Chopin A-minor Etude, Op. 10 No. 2! His Liszt Transcendental Etude (Wilde Jagd - Wild Hunt) faltered just a tiny bit, but this guy is for sure the real thing.

Daniel Kharitonov (Russia) - Once again, incredible finish allied to fantastic brilliance in his playing. I feel that his Appassionata, although perhaps not quite foreboding enough at the very opening, was worthy of comparison with such great performances as those by Richter and Moravec!

If Geniusas and Kharitonov don't make it to the next round, it's a scandal IMHO!

I make the next few predictions with less certainty, because it's partly a matter of taste. Often, I tend to go for "outside the box" playing, and these next three are kind of "misfits" in one way or another:

Moye Chen (China) - This guy has been going to the Lang Lang School of Facial Expressions. Really, he has to be seen to be believed, nowhere moreso than in his opening Bach Prelude and Fugue in F-sharp major (Book II). You look at this guy, and you actually think something may be wrong with him - like he's an idiot savant or something. But the actual playing is imaginative and quite accomplished - a very interesting player, although I thought his Chopin "Aeolian Harp" Etude was a bit too heavy, with the non-melody arpeggios insufficiently subdued. (But I don't want to have to look at him!)

Dinara Klinton (Russia) - Another one who goes crazy with the facial expressions, as well as calculated arm motion and body rocking. It's as if she heard some teacher say that "music has to tell a story", so she has completely rehearsed how she's going to act it out - with enough exaggeration so that the idiots in the audience (i.e., you and I) don't miss it! ;-) Nevertheless, she plays very well too, and, more importantly, very imaginatively. I'd d love to see her get to the next round (if the judges aren't too dissuaded by her physical antics!).

Dmitry Onishenko (Russia) - One of these Buddha-looking players who has a way of contorting his face that's also distracting (although not to the extent of Chen and Klinton). He also has this habit of looking out blankly about half way between the stage and the audience. Of the many first-rounders who played Liszt's "Chasse-Neige" Transcendental Etude, I thought Onishenko played with notable definition and expression.

Finally, I still think Maria Mazo (Germany) should make it, even though I've revised my opinion of her performances downward a bit in light of what I heard from the others on subsequent days - especially her Appassionata performance compared to the consummate performance of this work by Kharitonov. She still impressed me with the polish of her playing compared to most of the other competitors.

Some general notes:
  • The amount overlapping repertoire (Appassionata, Chasse-neige, Chopin Etudes in octaves and thirds, etc.) was a bit surprising.
  • Most of the pianists chose the Steinway to play on, although there were a few who chose the Yamaha (e.g., Onishenko), the Kawai (e.g., Chen), or the Faz (e.g., Mazo).
  • There was a surprising lack of babes in the piano section this year. Julia Kociuban (Poland) turned out to be on the pudgy side and didn't play that well in any case. The only real babe IMHO was Marina Yakhlakova (Russia), who also, I thought, didn't play well enough to pass to the next round.
  • I wonder if there might be any political pressure to choose competitors from adjoining countries (to show them "Russia is your friend, so get rid of your NATO missiles!"). Under this scenario, someone like Kociuban might indeed be passed to the next round. LOL!

I'm listening to the last competitor right now, Dmitry Masleev (Russia) playing Beethoven's Les Adieux Sonata - very good performance, but possibly a bit too many mistakes and smudges? These big competitions are pressure cookers!

 

Hide full thread outline!
    ...
Judges didn't like my "misfits" - I'm only batting .500, posted on June 20, 2015 at 15:43:54
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012
So here are the twelve pianists that the jury passed into the second round (with some comments I can't resist making):

Lucas Debargue (France - Yamaha)
Lukas Geniusas (Russia/Lithuania - Steinway)
Daniel Kharitonov (Russia - Steinway)
Julia Kociuban (Poland - Steinway)
George Li (USA - Steinway)
Dmitry Masleev (Russia - Steinway)
Maria Mazo (Germany - Fazioli)
Nikolay Medvedev (Russia - Steinway)
Ilya Rashkovskiy (Russia - Yamaha)
Sergey Redkin (Russia - Yamaha)
Reed Tetzloff (USA - Steinway)
Mikhail Turpanov (Russia - Steinway)

So. . . no scandal: both Geniusas and Kharitonov are into the second round! BTW, I didn't know that Kharitonov has been known in Russia as "The Prodigy" - there are some YouTube videos of him playing when he was 11. I thought the US competitors were not that special or memorable, but see my "political" theory about Kociuban in my OP - it may also apply to US competitors. ;-)

Some of the Russians (Rashkovsky, Turpanov) were ones I hadn't heard. Madeline and I plan to do spot checks of these folks tonight. In general though (perhaps with the exception of Kociuban), I can understand why the jury chose the candidates they did.

The second round starts tomorrow - no rest for the weary! ;-)

 

RE: Judges didn't like my "misfits" - I'm only batting .500, posted on June 20, 2015 at 16:47:44




Is your theory about Julia that the jury is allowing a token pudgy "non-babe" to advance?

 

If only she still looked like that picture in your post, posted on June 20, 2015 at 18:12:38
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012
I'm afraid she's really letting herself go. Alas, these days, she looks more like this:



I don't know how much of the original live broadcast of her round one performances is captured on her saved file at the medici tv site, but she was doing jumping jacks before she entered the stage. Apparently, she's not doing enough of them - not a good transformation! ;-)

 

Thanks for posting. Really enjoy reading your thoughts (nt), posted on June 20, 2015 at 18:18:46
krisjan
Reviewer

Posts: 929
Joined: May 6, 2001
.

 

BTW, for contrast. . . , posted on June 20, 2015 at 18:37:38
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012
Here's the way Marina Yakhlakova looked a couple of years ago (those eyes!):



And here's the way she looked (more or less) at the Tchaikovsky Competition:



A little more severe, but just as babeliocious - Too bad she didn't play better!

 

Thanks, krisjan! - it's quite an expenditure of time [nt], posted on June 20, 2015 at 18:42:27
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012

 

Ah, Chris, you're losing your touch., posted on June 20, 2015 at 20:13:25
The only real difference between those two photos is due to a professional photographer, a hair and makeup artist, and maybe even a fashion consultant, all no doubt hired by her management company looking to produce a glamorous stock photo.

Can you really tell which photo came first, yours or mine?

Glamor is ephemeral and superficial, my friend, and the viewer is easily fooled, especially by carefully posed still photos, perhaps even wants to be fooled.

Julia has a cute cherubic face and nice smile, but looking at a selection of her photos on the net, it seems she isn't interested in looking glamorous for your benefit, with a rare exception that was probably arranged by her management. Good for her, seems she's more of a babe than most of the ersatz babes you tout here.

 

I enjoyed Shino Hidaka, posted on June 20, 2015 at 22:53:30
jazz1
Audiophile

Posts: 2891
Joined: October 30, 2000
and her repertoire

 

I don't know, Roy. . . , posted on June 20, 2015 at 23:58:49
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012
. . . what you wrote is well said, but I WANT babe musicians to look glamorous for my benefit. If Marina can do it, Julia can do it too! ;-)

BTW, Madeline and I reviewed parts of the first round recitals by all the finalists tonight, and she agrees with me that there's something fishy about Julia's pass into the finals.

 

She was another one I unfortunately missed - on too early my time [nt], posted on June 21, 2015 at 00:05:45
Posts: 26434
Location: SF Bay Area
Joined: February 17, 2004
Contributor
  Since:
February 6, 2012

 

I'll have to listen to some of those contestants, posted on June 21, 2015 at 06:29:29
but life wouldn't be nearly what it is if we all agreed on exactly what makes a babe a babe.
I quote from one of the greatest classics:

There is nothing like a dame,
Nothing in the world.
There is nothing you can name
That is anything like a dame.

 

As in Dame Myra Hess? pic alert..., posted on June 21, 2015 at 15:18:14
krisjan
Reviewer

Posts: 929
Joined: May 6, 2001



This is the first Dame that came to mind...

 

Or maybe an earlier pic is more apt..., posted on June 21, 2015 at 15:20:00
krisjan
Reviewer

Posts: 929
Joined: May 6, 2001



Mo' better at least by a little..

 

She looks like a strong, self-confident leader., posted on June 21, 2015 at 17:43:18
Pictures sometimes do tell the true story, I guess.

 

Page processed in 0.028 seconds.