|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
5.66.112.191
In Reply to: RE: Shock horror! We're criticising Miles and Michael Brecker! posted by Rick W on January 19, 2022 at 11:42:01
Artists would get nowhere without a highly developed critical faculty. Mostly - in the interests of developing their art - directed at themselves and everything they produce, play or compose. A true artist who is not self-critical surely does not exist.
So I don't really follow you when you say "I fail to see what the point of negative posts about specific musicians is." I forget the famous Downbeat interview when a jazz musician rated all the tracks he was presented with with the maximum number of stars "just for being able to survive in the profession". And I and others surely felt a lot of sympathy with him.
But let's be free to call out musicians as we experience them. If nobody used their critical faculties to express likes and dislikes, what kind of a boring place would this be? Sounds like a kind of hippie dream world, not that we probably didn't all have our (very enjoyable) hippie moments....
I'm oblivious to Mike's other posts so I'll pass on that.
Follow Ups:
You apparently think you were unable to post your views in spite of the fact that they're on this page. I think I'm allowed to express my view of what you or others post too, which I did. If you wanna post to comment on the specifics of what I had to say about the piece on Brecker who's stopping you? If you can't see the difference between an artist being self-critical and Mike posting his umpteenth negative post about Miles you have my condolences.
Since this forum was created I've been the mod here. IIRC no posts have been deleted, two were moved to more appropriate forums.
I never said this was about deleting posts - I respect your record for that, of course. And once again, I have absolutely no knowledge about Mike's other posts. I'm just making a general comment about saying what we do or don't like, which is pretty normal, isn't it?
But when our "criticism" is your "negative shit"..............?
Not sure Rick would have said what he said for no valid reason. Mike K. reveres Paul Whiteman, BTW.
Edits: 01/21/22
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: