|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
77.111.246.14
In Reply to: RE: How did you come by your love of classical music? posted by tinear on October 31, 2020 at 07:23:02
. . . of one of Schubert's most famous chamber music works:
I expect to be told soon how this is wrong on so many levels and how this early musical experience must have warped me for life! ;-)
Follow Ups:
I recently downloaded the Doric's Death and the Maiden. On Lp, I listened to the Juilliard's quite a bit.
Best I can say: It's "nice," and tunes are "catchy."
The 15th is so much more interesting, IMHO.
are nowhere near as interesting as the first two? Like they belong in another quartet.
Not so with no. 14.
Recordings of 15 that I love: Italiano, Alban Berg, Prazak, Tokyo (1990s RCA),
And, not to answer for jdaniel, but I think the last couple of movements of the quartet are exactly what's needed at the point at which they occur. That main subject of the finale, with its peculiar use of the major and minor modes in the same theme is a real ear-worm for me and always sustains my interest. YMMV and all that.
I also liked the recording by the Panocha Quartet on CD, although I no longer have the physical disc.
n
My last 15th Quartet was Vienna Konzerhaus on Westminster in shockingly realistic mono sound, and last Quintet recording I owned was Collegium Aureum on DHM.
Jdaniel, I am assuming you mean the C+ quintet, in which case, though I've found no "perfect" performance of this extraordinary work, I prefer the Berg + Schiff. Certain pieces, y'know, one has an idea in one's mind of how the composer intended them even if one has never heard that completely realized. But the Berg with Schiff are pretty damn good, closer than others so far, for me.
Jeremy
,
Maybe you thought he was referring to Andras Schiff instead of Heinrich Schiff? ;-)
.
d
.
I'd give it an A+ (though it would still be in C+). I could have said "the C quintet", but then you'd have thought it even worse.
Jeremy
And I loved that Jules Maidoff cover art on many of the Artia and Parliament LP's from that era!
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: