Speaker Asylum

RE: Marten Speakers

209.197.142.190

This Post Has Been Edited by the Author

In Reply to: RE: Marten Speakers posted by RGA on January 16, 2017 at 16:04:02

k, so your only talking about maggies? if so, id agree that its fine if you dont like maggies and many cannot live with their sound no matter how long you try to live with it!
but you also mentioned Martin Logan which has dynamic driver for bass and they are totally diferent animals then maggies. same with janszen. Just hope you dont put all in the same boat
you actually said:"There is the positive review and there is the thing the reviewer is truly passionate about. It is very possible for me to review something that I very much like because in fact I do. Take ATC - I like the sound - there is a cut through it like a knife exacting nature to them. Full marks. Great - but would it be desert island sound? No. Nothing against ATC - great build big drive and power (especially the actives)."
have you had the ATC SCM50ASL or ATC SCM100ASL in your system for a couple of weeks?

part of my point is that when you compare 2 dynamic speakers that are excellent, it takes more then a audition at a dealer or show to really get if you can live with the speaker or not. many times my first impression on audition is far from definitive.

Edits: 01/16/17 01/16/17 01/16/17 01/16/17 01/16/17 01/16/17

Follow Ups: