In Reply to: BIS Sibelius #7 Vanska/Minnesota: Fabulous recording, unfussy interpretation, recommended! posted by jdaniel@jps.net on September 13, 2016 at 08:23:27:
It's hard for me to imagine Karajan being replaced in the 5th, or Barbirolli/Maazel/Szell for the 2nd, (though Szell just misses the transcendence of the final pages, as is his wont). >>>
Not on my agenda - Maazel, Barbirolli, Bernstein, Karajan.... Szell's always a maybe.
On my agenda - most of the Baltic and Scandinavian conductors, except Berglund who I've never liked much.
I lived in Norway for 6 years. I spoke the language and was very interested in the culture - I gigged all over Norway and did a lot of school tours as well. I need my Sibelius to feel "Nordic" with all that brings to the table. Just like I like my Falla to be played by Spaniards. It's in the blood, and it isn't your typical European symphonic tradition either.
I haven't heard the latest Vanska, but I like what he's done so far. Together with Segerstam, Kajanus, Jarvi, Saraste and some of the others, plus a few Russians and some conductors who sympathise with the music.
But as with Mahler, I don't like a lot of rhetoric or "added passion". I want to just hear the music. So for Mahler it's Boulez, Gielen, Rosbaud, Maderna. I don't think they recorded much Sibelius between them, though..... Don't know why Boulez wasn't big on SIbelius - no doubt he said something about it to somebody.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I like my Sibelius very Nordic.... No bombast please.... - andy evans 12:09:32 09/14/16 (9)
- RE: "Nordic" feeling - genungo 06:55:28 09/16/16 (4)
- That's what I was wondering too! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 11:13:40 09/16/16 (3)
- RE: That's what I was wondering too! - genungo 11:30:33 09/16/16 (2)
- Nordic for me.... - andy evans 12:18:08 09/16/16 (1)
- RE: Nordic for me.... - genungo 16:30:01 09/16/16 (0)
- RE: I like my Sibelius very Nordic.... No bombast please.... - Frihed89 14:44:00 09/15/16 (1)
- Danish and Norwegian... - andy evans 02:53:38 09/16/16 (0)
- Sibelius 7: Szell, Cleveland Orchestra - pbarach 16:06:46 09/14/16 (1)
- RE: Sibelius 7: Szell, Cleveland Orchestra - Todd Krieger 00:44:59 09/15/16 (0)